2. Specialist areas and related disciplines
As
a discipline, anthropology has numerous specialist sub-fields and
is closely allied to other human sciences. In this chapter we have
assembled brief descriptions of some of the main areas of specialisation.
The following accounts have been written by experts in the different
fields and are accompanied by short bibliographies which also give
an indication of the content and level of the works cited.
Archaeology and Anthropology
Matthew
H. Johnson University of Durham
Archaeology
is the study of past human societies through their material remains.
As such, it can be seen as one branch of anthropology. Indeed, in
North America archaeology is taught as one of the four subfields
of anthropological study. Many of the 'big questions' studied by
archaeologists are of general anthropological interest. The issues
of joint concern include: the study of early hominids and of the
origins of Homo sapiens;
the transition between gatherer-hunter ways of life
and of settled agriculture;
social evolution and the 'rise of social complexity', in
particular the origins and development of early state societies.
Archaeologists employ a range of techniques to find out about past
human groups. In addition to excavation, these include surveying
landscapes, examining buildings and analysing artefacts. They frequently
use parallels with contemporary societies in their interpretations,
for example when asking questions about past trade networks, agricultural
systems or religious belief.
Traditionally,
archaeology has been concerned with the distant past. In recent
years, however, the archaeology of more recent historical periods
and the study of material culture in the present have become increasingly
important. Archaeologists have asked what material things can tell
us of recent and modern societies. The subdiscipline of 'ethnoarchaeology'
studies societies and their material culture in the present. Archaeology
and cultural anthropology increasingly share a range of common
theoretical concerns including gender, symbolism, the role
of narrative and questions of history and cultural identity.
Suggested Readings
Johnson,
M.H.
1999 Archaeological
Theory: An Introduction, Oxford: Blackwell
[An
introduction to the basic concepts of archaeological thought.]
Layton,
R.H. (ed.)
1989 Conflicts on the Archaeology of Living Traditions, London:
Unwin Hyman
[This
book raises a series of concerns within the anthropology of archaeological
research.]
Leakey,
R. & Lewin R. 1992
Origins Reconsidered: In Search of what Makes us Human,
London: Little, Brown and Co
[An
accessible introduction to some of the issues of hominid evolution.]
Renfrew,
A.C. & Bahn P.
1996 Archaeology:
Theories, Methods and Practice, London: Thames and Hudson
[The
best all-round student introduction to the subject.]
Scarre,
C. (ed.)
1988 The Times Atlas of Archaeology, London: Times Books
[A
summary of some of the main empirical findings of the discipline
over the last thirty years.]
Art and Anthropology
Jeremy
Coote University of Oxford
The
anthropology of art studies and analyses the wide range of material
objects produced by people around the world. These are considered
not merely as aesthetic objects but are understood to play a wider
role in people's lives, for instance in their beliefs and rituals.
The materials studied include sculpture, masks, paintings, textiles,
baskets, pots, weapons, and the human body itself. Anthropologists
are interested in the symbolic meanings encoded in such objects,
as well as in the materials and techniques used to produce them.
The
anthropology of art overlaps with art history, aesthetics, material
culture studies, and visual anthropology. However, the anthropological
approach to art is distinguished by its focus on the social processes
involved in making objects. So, whereas art historians might be
interested in the work and lives of named individuals,
anthropologists of art are more concerned with the role and
status of the artist in the wider community. Another central concern
of this branch of the discipline has been to analyse the form and
function of objects and to explore the relations between these and
aspects of the wider society.
Since
the 1960s in particular, anthropologists have produced increasingly
sophisticated analyses of visual materials. More recently, closer
attention has been paid to the different ideas of aesthetic value
in different societies. Increasing attention has also been paid
to the ways in which material objects made in one sphere come to
have value in another. For example, there have been a number of
recent studies of the tourist and art markets as well as of the
role of museums.
Suggested Readings
Baxandall,
M. 1972
Painting and Experience in Fifteenth-Century Italy: A
Primer in the Social History of Pictorial Style, Oxford: Oxford
University Press
[The
work of an art historian rather than an anthropologist, this is
included here as it is one of the most successful demonstrations
of how to marshal material to produce an insider's view of an art
tradition.]
Coote,
J. & Shelton, A.
(eds) 1992
Anthropology, Art, And Aesthetics (Oxford Studies
in the Anthropology of Cultural Forms), Oxford: Clarendon Press
[A
recent collection of original essays in the field, this contains
a number of important contributions to the subject. The essays by
Jeremy Coote, Alfred Gell, and Howard Morphy have been particularly
influential.]
Forge,
A. (ed.)
1973 Primitive Art and Society, London: Oxford University.
Press for the Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research
[A
classic collection of essays from which the subject today traces
its origins. With particularly influential contributions from Gregory
Bateson, Anthony Forge, Edmund Leach, and Nancy Munn.]
Guss,
D.M.
1989 To Weave
and Sing: Art, Symbol, and Narrative in the South American Rain
Forest, Berkeley: University of California Press
[Lucid
analysis of the basketry of the Yekuana of Venezuela in relation
to Yekuana cosmology. The author shows how basketry provides the
medium for the resolution of cosmological problems.]
Layton,
R.
1991 The
Anthropology of Art, Frogmore: Granada (2nd edn), Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press
[Still
a useful account, though the rapid growth of the subject - and related
subjects - in the last fifteen years means that on its own it no
longer provides an adequate introduction.]
Morphy,
H. 1991
Ancestral Connections: Art and an Aboriginal System of
Knowledge, Chicago: University of Chicago Press
[Detailed
and accessible study, using both art-historical and anthropological
methods, of the meanings and changing social importance of bark
painting among the Yolngu people of Northeast Arnhem Land.]
O'Hanlon,
M.
1989 Reading
the Skin: Adornment, Display and Society among the Wahgi, London:
British Museum Publications for the Trustees of the British Museum
[Accessible
and beautifully illustrated account of body adornment among the
Wahgi of Papua New Guinea. Focusing on indigenous evaluation, the
study explores the relations between appearance, morality, and politics.]
Children, Childhood
and Anthropology: the
study of the early years of human life in different cultural settings
Allison
James University of Hull
The
anthropology of childhood is a relatively new field for anthropological
study which emerged in Britain during the 1970s and contrasts with
the earlier culture and personality studies conducted by American
anthropologists such as Margaret Mead during the 1940s and 50s.
These studies were primarily interested in exploring how processes
of socialisation and cultural transmission take place during childhood.
However, in these accounts, little attention was given to children's
own active role in these socialising processes. The focus was instead
on the mechanisms through which culture passed between the generations.
Contemporary
work on childhood, by contrast, sees children as social actors in
their own right and seeks to document their perspectives on, and
participation in, the social world. This approach acknowledges that
children experience different kinds of childhood in different societies
and questions whether childhood should be seen as a cultural universal.
Contemporary anthropological studies of childhood also recognise
that, although children may not occupy central social, political
and economic roles in society, it is important to see that they
can and do make an active contribution. This may take place through,
for example, their membership of peer groups and of families and
their participation in leisure, work and schooling. An anthropology
of childhood seeks to understand the different social worlds of
children and how children learn about the adult social world to
which they will eventually belong.
Suggested Readings
Amit-Talai,
V. & H. Wulff (eds)
1995 Youth
Cultures: A Cross-cultural Perspective, London: Routledge
[One
of the very few collections available on the topic of youth cultures.
Some articles may be suitable for motivated sixth formers but this
book would constitute a useful resource for teachers.]
Frankin,
B.
1995 The
Handbook of Children's Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice,
London: Routledge
[A
series of articles which considers the implications of the UN Convention
on the Rights of the Child - a central issue in the debates about
childhood cross culturally. Suitable as a resource to spark off
discussion.]
James,
A. 1993
Childhood Identities, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press
[A
case study of children's lives at school in Britain which discusses
the different influences on their games and friendships. The later
chapters are less theoretical and therefore more accessible.]
James,
A. & A. Prout (eds)
1997 Constructing
and Reconstructing Childhood, London: Falmer Press
[A
collection of articles providing an overview of recent new studies
of the history of childhood, developmental psychology, images of
childhood, age and competence, child sexual abuse, street children
and the globalisation of childhood.]
Nieuwenhuys,
O. 1994
Children's Lifeworlds. London: Routledge
[A
case study of working children in India which looks at boys'
and girls' contributions to household production. A good introduction
to the sensitive issues surrounding child labour.]
Stephens,
A. (ed.)
1995 Children and the Politics of Culture, Princeton University
Press
[A
comprehensive collection of essays which deal with some of the difficult
issues children face in different parts of the world as a result
of state interventions into their lives.]
Development and Anthropology: the
study of the impact of development on traditional societies and
communities
Paul
Sillitoe University of Durham
Development
refers to the strategies which aim to transfer resources and assistance
from the world's economically richer nations to poorer nations.
This transfer can occur either directly (known as bilateral aid
- eg the UK government's Department for International Development)
or indirectly (known as multilateral aid - eg the UN's various agencies
like the Food and Agriculture Organisation). Development is a somewhat
unhappy notion because it implies improvement, which is not always
the experience of those subjected to economic development programmes.
Anthropologists have demonstrated how technological and economic
innovations invariably bring other changes in their train, which
may not be perceived by all those caught up in them, in the short-term
at least, as desirable or in their interests. Distressing social
consequences of development can more than cancel out any material
benefits. The disturbance and bewilderment experienced by people
when changes proceed swiftly have been well documented by anthropologists.
The
realisation that development programmes have been responsible for
undesirable and unsustainable change, often involving a considerable
waste of resources, has promoted a fundamental re-think of the very
idea of development. Previously,
governments and international agencies imposed interventions
on the so-called ignorant poor who were thought to demand modernisation.
Economists, technocrats and policymakers dominated this process
and anthropology had scarcely any meaningful part to play other
than as critic of the sometimes devastating consequences. The field
of applied anthropology was marginal to the carrying out
of these programmes. Today, development agencies are increasingly
interested in facilitating initiatives which promote the participation
of the poor and, with the assistance of anthropologists, are paying
closer attention to indigenous systems of knowledge and understanding.
Non-government organisations have played a prominent part in promoting
this grass-roots perspective. It is a perspective which offers anthropology
a central role in development practice.
Suggested Readings
Burkey,
S. 1994
People First: A Guide to Self-reliant Participatory Rural
Development, London: Zed Books
[A
readable introduction to the participatory approach to development,
arguing passionately for the involvement of the poor in planning
and implementing interventions that affect their lives.]
Chambers,
R.
1993 Challenging
the Professions: Frontiers for Rural Development, London: Intermediate
Technology Publications
[A
provocative and easily read book by one of the principal advocates
of participatory approaches to development. It challenges the expert
status of development practitioners and argues for fundamental changes
in approach.]
Gardner,
K. & Lewis, D.
1996 Anthropology,
Development and the Post-Modern Challenge, London: Pluto Press
[An
accessible introductory text to the major themes of development
as they relate to contemporary anthropology.]
Long,
N. & Long, A. (eds)
Battlefields of Knowledge: The Interlocking of Theory
and Practice in Social Research and Development, London: Routledge
[A
collection of essays that explores the difficult negotiations between
different stakeholders with different world views and aspirations,
and the contorted power relations that characterise development.]
Okali,
C., Sumberg, J. & Farrington, J.
1994 Farmer
Participatory Research, London: Intermediate Technology Publications
[A
text outlining the use of participatory methods in agricultural
research in lesser developed countries and attendant problems.]
Warren,
D. M., Skillerveer, L. J. & Brokensha, D.
1995 The
Cultural Dimensions of Development: Indigenous Knowledge Systems,
London: Intermediate Technology Publications
[A
large collection of essays, including several case studies, on the
integration of indigenous knowledge into the development process.
Useful for giving students a feel for some of the practical issues.]
Ecological Anthropology:
the study of
humans, resources and environments
Tim
Ingold University of Manchester
Ecological
anthropology studies the relations between human beings and their
environments. Its foundations were laid by Julian Steward in the
mid-twentieth century. Steward emphasised the dynamic, two-way nature
of the culture-environment relation, and the importance of the concept
of adaptation in understanding it. Steward distinguished 'cultural'
from 'biological' ecology on the grounds that the former was about
the adaptation of culture as a system existing outside of individual
human organisms. By contrast, in the so-called 'new ecology' of
the 1960s, culture was seen as the means of environmental adaptation
of human populations. Theories developed in animal ecology were
considered applicable to humans as well. Drawing on one such theory,
of group selection, ecological anthropologists focused on how aspects
of cultural behaviour maintain balance or 'homeostasis' in the relations
between a local group and its environmental resources, and so promote
its long-term survival.
In
the 1970s and 1980s, ecological anthropology was overtaken by sociobiology.
Emphasising the gene rather than the group as the unit of selection,
sociobiologists argued that the adaptive role of cultural behaviour
is to contribute to the representation of individuals' genes in
future generations. One recent offshoot of sociobiology, 'evolutionary
behavioural ecology', is dedicated to showing how adaptive strategies
established through natural selection are played out under variable
environmental conditions. For example, studies of human foraging
have explained the relationship between food procurement patterns
and energy returns. During the 1990s, however, a quite different
trend has emerged in ecological anthropology. This approach looks
at the totality of relations existing between persons and their
environments and privileges neither genetics nor culture in explanations
of human action and perception.
Suggested Readings
Croll,
E. & Parkin, D. (eds)
1992 Bush
Base: Forest Farm, Culture, Environment and Development, London:
Routledge
[A
series of case studies, preceded by three introductory chapters,
exploring the relevance of peoples' cultural understandings of their
environments for development programmes, especially in the Third
World.]
Ellen,
R.
1982 Environment,
Subsistence and System: The Ecology of Small-scale Social Formations,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
[One
of the most comprehensive and wide-ranging texts in ecological anthropology.
Though packed with information and with an extensive bibliography,
it is fairly heavy going as an introductory text.]
Ingold,
T.
1986 The
Appropriation of Nature: Essays on Human Ecology and Social Relations,
Manchester: Manchester University Press
[A
series of original essays exploring the interplay between social
and ecological relations. The author contrasts human hunting and
gathering to non-human foraging as well as to pastoralism and cultivation.
The work challenges basic assumptions about humanity and animality.]
Milton,
K.
1996 Environmentalism
and Cultural Theory: Exploring the Role of Anthropology in Environmental
Discourse, London: Routledge
[This
book compares the cultural approach to the study of environmental
issues with other established approaches. It brings out the distinctive
contribution of anthropology to the environmental debate and adds
significantly to our understanding of environmentalism as a contemporary
phenomenon.]
Rappaport,
R.
1984 Pigs
for the Ancestors: Ritual in the Ecology of a New Guinea People,
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
[A
classic study of ecology and ritual relationships among Highland
New Guinea cultivators. The book, originally published in 1968,
has been much debated and since reissued in an enlarged edition
with a retrospective commentary by the author. A central text in
ecological anthropology.]
Steward,
J.H.
1955 Theory
of Culture Change, Urbana: University of Illinois Press
[This
was the book that effectively launched cultural ecology and is the
foundation for all subsequent work in ecological anthropology. Dated
now, but still a basic text in the field.]
Economic Anthropology:
the study of systems of production and exchange
James
G. Carrier University of Durham
Economic
anthropologists study processes of production, circulation and consumption
of different sorts of objects in social settings. 'Objects' includes
material things, as well as what people do for each other (such
as provide labour and services) and less visible objects (such as
names, ideas and so forth). The settings range from small and intimate
social units like households through intermediate ones, like firms,
villages or local markets, to very large entities like regional
systems of ceremonial exchange or global systems of advertising
and consumption.
While
the settings and processes that are studied vary tremendously, most
economic anthropologists approach them in two main ways. One approach
is concerned with social context: what sorts of people make, give,
take or consume which sorts of things, and in what sorts of situations
do they do so? In a sub-Saharan African village, who is it who tends
food crops - men or women, old or young, married or single, and
so forth? In England, which sorts of households are likely to have
computers, and which household members are likely to use them?
Another approach is concerned with cultural context: how
do different sorts of people understand their economic activities,
the objects involved and the people with whom they carry out those
activities? When an artisan sells something to a buyer, how does
each party think about their relationship and the objects that they
exchange?
Thus,
while economic anthropologists study economic processes, their approach
is different from that of economists. Economists usually restrict
themselves to monetary transactions and try to develop formal, abstract
models of economic systems. Economic anthropologists, on the other
hand, usually are concerned with all forms of production, circulation
and consumption, monetary or not. Further, they are concerned less
with developing formal models and more with trying to describe and
understand economic actions in their social and cultural context.
Suggested Readings
Davis,
J. 1992
Exchange, Buckingham: Open University Press
[A
brief, general discussion of the nature of exchange in many settings;
particularly useful in helping students think about exchange in
western societies.]
Gudeman,
S. & Rivera, A.
1991 Conversations
in Columbia: The Domestic Economy in Life and Text, Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press
[A
close analysis of the ways that peasants in Colombia think about
their economic activities, and how this compares with what many
westerners think.]
Mars,
G. 1994
(1982) Cheats at
Work: An Anthropology of Workplace Crime, Aldershot: George
Allen & Unwin, Dartmouth Press
[Often
amusing, this is a careful study of petty crime at work. Largely
focused on Britain, it points out how the social organisation of
labour affects the ways that workers think and act in the workplace.]
Miller,
D. 1994
Unwrapping Christmas, Oxford: Oxford University Press
[Around
Christmas there is a tremendous amount of economic activity. This
collection of essays, primarily focusing on the West, considers
how people think about Christmas buying and giving. Some papers
are more accessible than others.]
Pahl,
R.E. 1984
Divisions of Labour, Oxford: Basil Blackwell
[Occasionally
a bit technical and dry, this work describes the relationship between
work and unemployment. It ranges from an historical treatment of
productive and wage labour to an analysis of who does what work
around the house in the Isle of Sheppey in the 1970s and 1980s.
Useful for showing the range of productive work in the modern West.]
Silverstone
R. & Hirsch, E. (eds)
1992 Consuming
Technologies: Media and Information in Domestic Spaces, London:
Routledge
[A
collection of papers. The more accessible describe how different
sets of people, primarily in Britain, use and think about electronic
media, ranging from telephones to computer games and television
programmes.]
Wilk,
R. 1996
Economies and Cultures, Boulder: Westview Press
[Oriented
strongly to Americans, this is written as an undergraduate textbook
on economic anthropology. It is useful especially for laying out
the different ways that anthropologists think about economic activity.]
Ethnicity and Anthropology:
the study of
ethnic identities and interactions
Tamara
Kohn University of Durham
Ethnicity
is a term used to express differences between groups of people.
In socio-cultural anthropology, the study of ethnicity tends to
look at relationships between groups that see themselves, and are
considered by others, to be culturally distinctive. For example,
some anthropologists look at the various ways people express their
differences from others (through markers such as language, dress,
religious belief, food, ideas about shared history, etc). Others
look at the relations between different ethnic groups in multicultural
societies in times of peace and war/conflict. While other disciplines
(eg political science, economics, history, etc) have concentrated
on the larger global forces which influence ethnicity, anthropologists
have tended to begin with the inside, 'experienced' view of the
people they have lived and worked with. If ethnicity is generally
concerned with how groups set themselves apart or derive a sense
of 'we' or 'us', race has been more concerned with how people set
other groups apart by setting up distinction between 'us' and 'them'.
This setting apart involves the stereotyping of others and their
practices, and is often the basis of racism, discrimination and
violence. Anthropologists are interested in the ways that the sentiments
and ideas associated with ethnicity and race are expressed in everyday
life.
Suggested Readings
Banks,
M.
1996 Ethnicity:
Anthropological Constructions, London: Routledge
[This
book maps out the different approaches that anthropologists have
taken to the study of ethnicity. It is particularly useful for those
who want to understand how concepts of ethnicity and race are related,
and uses examples ranging from ethnic cleansing in Bosnia to minority
experience in Britain or the USA.]
Benson,
S. 1981
Ambiguous Ethnicity: Interracial Families in London,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
[This
case study looks at the experiences of couples in mixed marriages
in Brixton in the 1970s. The biggest problems faced by the Anglo-Caribbean
and Anglo-African families at that time were due to the ambiguities
they experienced regarding their ethnic identity.]
Eriksen,
T.H.
1993 Ethnicity
and Nationalism: Anthropological Perspectives, London: Pluto
Press
[This
is an excellent introduction which uses examples from all over the
world. Eriksen discusses theories which anthropologists have used to understand the
ways that people define themselves vis-à-vis others.]
Glazer,
N. & Moynihan, D.P. (eds)
1975 Ethnicity:
Theory and Experience, Cambridge and London: Harvard University
Press
[This
is a very useful text (if somewhat dated) which stresses the relevance
of the concept 'ethnicity'.]
Hutchinson,
J. & Smith. A.D. (eds)
1996 Ethnicity,
Oxford: Oxford University Press
[This
'reader' contains over sixty short excerpts from classic essays
and books on ethnicity. Some of these are about particular regions
in the world and others are more general/theoretical.]
Watson,
J. (ed.)
1977 Between
Two Cultures: Migrants and Minorities in Britain, Oxford: Blackwell
[This
case study looks at the way in which some migrants and minorities
feel themselves to be caught between two cultures. Chapters offer
examples from a wide range of ethnic groups in Britain (including
Polish, Sikh, Pakistani, Chinese, Turkish, Jamaican).]
Family and Kinship:
the study of
the social organisation of human reproduction
Tony
Good University of Edinburgh
Kinship
has always been central to social anthropology. The interest in
this topic grew out of nineteenth century debates in which families
in 'traditional' societies were seen as evolutionary precursors
of Victorian families. Even after anthropologists began studying
other societies in their own right rather than treating them as
living relics, kinship and the family retained their importance.
This is hardly surprising, as kinship is associated quite literally
with matters of life and death. An individual's family and relatives
usually constitute their most important social network.
However,
anthropologists have never fully agreed on what kinship is. Historically,
there was a clear division between those who saw it as based on
descent links between parents and children, and those who stressed
relationships created by marriage. In part, this difference in emphasis
reflected geographical differences, with Africa and Europe roughly
exemplifying the first model, and Asia, the second. Moreover, 'family'
has a range of meanings even in the contemporary UK. Family might
mean simply parents and children resident under the same roof or
it might be used to refer to a large number of people related by
birth and marriage.
The
view that relatives have 'blood' or some other physical attribute
in common is very widespread in human society. However, kinship
relationships are distinct from biological relationships. As human
physiology is the same everywhere,
variations in kinship ideas and practices must be social
and cultural in character. Much current academic and lay thinking
about kinship and family relationships is being challenged by recent
developments in reproductive technology.
Suggested Readings
Carsten,
J.
1997 The
Heat of the Hearth; the Process of Kinship in a Malay Fishing Community,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
[An
intimate study of kinship, showing how family relationships are
created and maintained by everyday processes of cooking and sharing
food. Written from the author's experience of being incorporated
as a foster daughter into a fishing family on Langkawi Island, Malaysia.]
Edwards,
J., Franklin, S., Hirsch, E., Price, F. & Strathern, M.
1993 Technologies
of Procreation: Kinship in the Age of Assisted Conception, Manchester:
Manchester University Press
[An
anthropological analysis of the views of doctors, MPs and ordinary
people in northern and southern England on the moral and legal implications
of new reproductive technologies such as egg donation and in vitro
fertilisation.]
Evans-Pritchard,
E.E. 1951
Kinship and Marriage among the Nuer, Oxford: Clarendon
Press
[A
truly classic study of kinship among Nuer cattle-herders of the
Sudan, with a particular focus on different forms of marriage and
the exchanges of cattle which accompany them.]
Fox,
R. 1996
[1967] Kinship and
Marriage: An Anthropological Perspective, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press
[A
standard and widely used introduction to the study of kinship. Fox
attaches more weight to the influence of biological factors on kinship
than do most contemporary anthropologists.]
Jeffery,
P., Jeffery, R. & Lyon, A.
1989 Labour
Pains and Labour Power, London: Zed Books
[Sets
the process of child-bearing into the general context of women's
lives in rural North India, focusing on family relationships and
the household economy. Makes vivid use of direct conversations with
rural women themselves.]
Keesing,
R.M.
1975 Kin
Groups and Social Culture, New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston
[Another
widely used introductory text on kinship, with a useful glossary
and helpful use of illustrative case studies.]
Parkin,
R.
1997 Kinship:
An Introduction to Basic Concepts, Oxford: Blackwell
[The
most recent general textbook on classic themes in the anthropological
study of kinship.]
Gender and Anthropology:
the study of
the experience and constructions of gender differences within and
across cultures
Judith
Okely University of Hull
Early
twentieth century anthropologists presumed that the social and political
differences or divisions between men and women were 'natural'. The
pioneering anthropologist Phyllis Kaberry, who did fieldwork among
Australian Aborigines in the 1930s, depicted women as 'active agents'.
Although her material reveals women not to be subservient, nonetheless
they are generally subordinate relative to men. Margaret Mead, who
also commenced fieldwork in the 1930s, while not concerned with
subordination, demonstrated that ideals of femininity and masculinity
vary enormously between groups. Her ideas continue to be relevant.
Thanks
to the Womens' Liberation Movement of the 1970s, a younger generation
of women began to question the masculinist orthodoxies in social
anthropology, both in the traditions in fieldwork and the literature.
An important distinction which began to be made was that between
sex as a biological given and gender as culturally variable. In
this way, it was argued that divisions of labour and different roles
assigned on the basis of gender were no longer accepted as biologically
inevitable. Whilst sex at birth is relatively fixed, the meanings
and behaviour associated with physical, sexual differences were
seen as fluid and varied across cultures. In the 1990s, the dichotomy
is held to be less clear, but even in the 1970s it was always recognised
that human biology could also be culturally transformed and manipulated.
From
the mid-1970s, a number of important volumes by women anthropologists
made women more visible and also raised key questions about gender
and anthropological theory. Contrary to subsequent caricatures in
later literature, this strategy never implied that women should
be studied separate from men and gender. Neither was it suggested
that women could be studied separate from men, nor did the material
suggest that women were universally the same. The vast cross-cultural
range of the early volumes already displayed differences among women.
Although masculinity is only recently being studied in detail, gender
studies aim to explore the full ranges of gender categories, including
androgyny, in different cultural contexts.
The
impact of gender studies is also apparent in relation to field work.
Early texts by women such as Elenore Smith Bowen and Hortense Powdermaker
demonstrated the importance of personal experience, individual identity
and social relationships in writing anthropology. Once marginalised,
these texts explored the ideas which are now central to the discipline.
Suggested Readings
Bell,
D., Caplan, P. & Karim, W.J. (eds)
1993 Engendered
Fields, London: Routledge
[This
collection explores the significance of gender for the anthropologist
in the field. It develops some of the themes developed by Smith-Bowen
and Powdermaker and explores new ones, including contributions by
male anthropologists, increasingly sensitive to gender and masculinity.]
Jeffrey,
P. 1979
Frogs in a Well: Indian Women in Purdah, London: Zed
Press
[An
accessible and beautifully presented study of women in purdah. The
anthropologist as a woman had unique access.]
Mead,
M.
1935 Sex
and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies, Harmondsworth:
Penguin
[This
is a classic study of different New Guinea groups, which challenges
the assumption that certain characteristics are universally 'masculine'
or 'feminine'.]
Oakley,
A.
1972 Sex,
Gender and Society, London: Temple Smith
[An
informed cross-cultural overview, drawing on a mass of anthropological
literature and which helped to popularise the distinction between
sex and gender.]
Okely,
J.
1996 Own
or Other Culture. London: Routledge
[This
contains articles from the 1970s to the mid-1990s. Questions of
gender and fieldwork are explored, especially in relation to Gypsies
and to anthropology in the West. Feminist theories and the impact
of the Women's Liberation Movement on cross-cultural studies are
explored, in an accessible style.]
Rosaldo,
M. & Lamphere, L. (eds)
1974 Women,
Culture and Society, Stanford: Stanford University Press
[A
pioneering collection of both general theoretical explorations into
women's subordination and detailed ethnographic case studies from
around the world. Fundamental questions were raised about gender
assumptions.]
Literature and Anthropology
Helen
Kanitkar School of Oriental and
African Studies, London
Only
recently have anthropologists turned their attention to novelists
indigenous to societies they study, recognising at last that these
writers are themselves useful informants who provide a way through
to a deeper understanding of other cultures, and a further channel
of communication between observer and observed. The power of all
literature to carry and convey traditional values, as well as to
challenge them, has been recorded already, and indigenous literatures
provide an immediate, empathic introduction to new cultural experience
of a type which cannot be acquired any other way. Frequently, tales
are told in the first person, a literary device which makes them
more involving and effective for readers.
Though
these novels have great value, students of anthropology should nevertheless
approach them warily. The writers are not anthropologists scrupulously
noting and annotating their observations in the field for future
analysis; readers cannot ask questions, pursue their own interests,
nor crosscheck information gleaned. The novelist's purpose is not
that of the social scientist and the material used by a writer is
not collected or described sequentially; rather, composite characters
and accumulated impressions are gathered from diverse scenarios
and built up through the author's evaluative interpretation to represent
the social tensions and co-operations that are the stuff of anthropological
research. The novelist is a channel linking two rivers of cultural
tradition; but as the nature of a channel can affect the water passing
through it, so novelists' perceptions may change or modify their
subject matter, often deliberately. They may present things not
as they are, but as the novelist would like them to be, thus, through
the small dramas of daily life, usefully pointing an anthropologist
towards processes of social change. Anthropologists are now keenly
aware of the influences of the 'self' in their ethnographic writing,
and struggle to avoid them, but novelists do not, and, it may be
argued, should not. If a novel is being read in translation there
is yet another interpretive filter through which representations
must pass, and readers therefore need extra awareness when enjoying
translated works.
In
spite of these cautions, the 'little ethnographies' that intersperse
these novels provide valuable and meaningful first glimpses of the
cultures within which they originate, encouraging readers towards
the satisfaction of personal encounter, the real excitement that
anthropology offers.
Suggested Readings
Achebe,
C.
1966 A Man
of the People, Oxford: Heinemann
[An
amusing satire dealing with scheming and corruption in the political
world, set in postcolonial Nigeria.]
Berry,
J.
1987 A Thief
in the Village and other Stories, London: Hamish Hamilton
[Village
life in the Caribbean, seen from the perspective of the children
of the community. Although of interest to young teenagers, the book
has much to say to adults too.]
Choa,
C. & LiQun, D.S.
1998 Picador
Book of Chinese Contemporary Fiction, London: Picador
[A
collection of modern Chinese short stories dealing with daily social
interaction. These tales are sensitive in development of character
and delineation of social change.]
Mahfouz,
N.
1992 The
Time and the Place, London: Doubleday
[Twenty
absorbing short stories, most of which have not appeared in English
before. They conjure up the processes and interaction of Egyptian
daily life with sensitivity and understanding.]
Mehta,
R.
1977 Inside
the Haveli, London: Women's Press
[Written
by an eminent Indian sociologist, the book tells of a young bride's
entry into purdah, her difficult adjustment to its demands, and
gradual personal development within its bounds until she is able,
very slowly, to instigate processes of social change.]
Mo,
T.
1993 The
Monkey King, London: Vintage Books
[Written
with humour and understanding, the novel explores family life within
the business community of postwar Hong Kong.]
Narayan,
R.K.
1993 The
Grandmother's Tale. London: Heinemann
[Three
novellas based in smalltown India, gently exploring a) a deserted
childbride's search for her husband and efforts to win him back;
b) the loneliness that a miser's money brings him; c) a childless
couple's unexpected route to wealth and fame.]
Medical Anthropology:
the comparative
study of systems of health and healing
Roland
Littlewood University College,
London
Medical
anthropology is a good example of how anthropologists have been
able to relate the natural sciences to the humanities. It is the
study of how people in different cultural settings experience health
and illness. Such experiences are examined in the light of a particular
community's knowledge about sickness and misfortune, in relation
to broader moral and religious ideas. Recent examples of the kinds
of studies undertaken by medical anthropologists include research
into the impact of AIDS on Central African societies, the consequences
of the traumas of war on families in Sri Lanka and Guatemala, the
impact of the new reproductive technologies (for example, in vitro
fertilisation) on British notions of 'the family', the impact of
malnutrition on Brazilian ideas of children's illness, the appearance
of new illnesses like multiple personality disorder and chronic
fatigue (Gulf War Syndrome) and the effects of migration on the
mental health of ethnic minority groups.
At
the moment, medical anthropology is trying to maintain its cultural
interest in questions of knowledge, meaning and politics in the
broader discipline of anthropology without becoming simply an 'applied'
sub-discipline. Graduates who have studied medical anthropology
are attracted to careers in international aid and social services,
and health professions such as nursing and clinical psychology.
Suggested Readings
Douglas,
M. (ed.)
1988 Constructive Drinking: Perspectives on Drink from Anthropology,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
[Lively
set of essays on the social context of alcohol.]
Helman,
C.
1990 Culture,
Health and Illness: An Introduction for HealthProfessionals (3rd
edn), London: Butterworth-Heinemann
[Readable
introductory account of medical symbolism and popular knowledge,
largely in a British context.]
Kiev,
A. (ed.)
1964 Magic, Faith and Healing, New York: Free Press
[Essays
on magic, therapy and shamanism in different countries.]
Littlewood,
R. & Lipsedge, M.
1997 Aliens
and Alienists: Ethnic Minorities and Psychiatry, London: Routledge
[Accessible
account for the general reader on ethnicity and cultural psychiatry.]
Tambiah,
S. J.
1990 Magic,
Science, Religion and the Scope of Rationality, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press
[A
more thought-provoking look at questions of the rationality of science
and medicine as core questions for social anthropologists.]
Performing Arts and
Anthropology: the
cross-cultural study of art, music and dance
Felicia
Hughes-Freeland University of Wales,
Swansea
The
anthropology of art has focused on material objects. Less attention
has been given to physical performance (music, dance, theatre) despite
pioneering work by anthropologists such as Victor Turner in recent
decades. Anthropological approaches to performance are different from performance studies and the
field of performance. Anthropologists explore the relationship between
society and the dramatic and artistic representations which it produces.
Anthropological approaches to performance reflect a range of anthropological
concerns: social structure, function, meaning, identity and experience.
The study of performing arts also has much in common
with the ethnography of ritual, a richly documented
field, but not always one in which the elements of performance are
given their due recognition. As such, anthropological studies of
performance are useful for teaching students about socio-cultural
diversity as well as the role of different theoretical perspectives
in the discipline. The anthropology of performance is a relatively
new field of enquiry, and therefore no simple introductions or general
readers are as yet available. However, many researchers have produced
papers and chapters in edited volumes. Below are identified some
of the most useful.
Suggested Readings
Blacking,
J.
1995 Music,
Culture and Experience, Chicago: Chicago University Press
[John
Blacking was a pioneer in the study of ethnomusicology. This collection
of papers identifies his specifically anthropological approach to
music and human creativity.]
Cohen,
A.
1993 Masquerade
Politics, Oxford: Berg
[This
book demonstrates the political nature of performance. It concentrates
on urban cultural movements and uses London's Notting Hill Carnival
as a case study.]
Hughes-Freeland,
F. (ed.)
1998 Ritual,
Performance, Media (ASA Monograph 35), London: Routledge
[This
collection explores ways of analysing ritual and social performance
in relation to theatre and the media, focusing on the tensions between
creativity and constraint. It provides a wide range of ethnographic
examples.]
Laderman,
C. & Roseman, M. (eds)
1996 The
Performance of Healing, London: Routledge
[A
novel set of ethnographic accounts of the different ways in which
performance is applied in the healing process.]
Schieffelin,
E. L.
1976 The
Sorrow of the Lonely and the Burning of the Dancers, New York:
St Martin's Press
[This
is the first study to analyse dance as part of social exchange.
After a clear account of the daily life of the Gisaro of Papua New
Guinea, the book examines a ritual called Kaluli. Schieffelin shows
how dancing and singing produce feelings which are important in
social transactions.]
Spencer,
P. (ed.)
1985 Society and the Dance, Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press
[This
is a useful introduction to the different ways of conceptualising
dance as a social activity, and includes chapters by some of the
most important anthropological scholars of performing arts.]
Turner,
V.W.
1992 The
Anthropology of Performance, New York: Performing Arts Journal
[This
collection of Turner's last essays explores performance from a number
of perspectives.]
Physical/Biological
Anthropology: the
study of the biological inheritance of the human species
Leslie
Aiello University College, London
Physical/
biological anthropology is the study of the past and present evolution
of the human species and is especially concerned with understanding
the causes of present human diversity. Within this broad definition
it encompasses fields as disparate as human palaeontology,
evolutionary biology, human genetics, comparative anatomy and physiology,
primate behaviour, sociobiology, and human biology. Human biology
broadly covers the areas of modern human biological variation, human
ecology, nutrition
and demography. What makes physical/ biological anthropology
unique is that it brings all of these areas to bear on our
understanding of the
human condition. Evolutionary perspectives encompass the origins
of modern humans and of modern human diversity; the relationship
between climate and human evolution; the evolution of language and
cognition. What underlies all of these areas is the interpretation
of archaeological and palaeontological evidence. Such evidence is
considered within the
broader theoretical context of
evolutionary biology and furthermore draws on evidence from
comparative morphology and behavioural research.
Evolutionary
studies also extend to modern human biological and behaviour variation.
One fascinating area of current interest is the degree to which
human behaviour is rooted in biology rather than culture. In the
general area of human ecology recent concerns emphasise the implications
for vulnerable human groups of changes in climate, land tenure and
economy. This area also impinges on questions of environmental conservation
in the modern world. These more recent interests in human ecology
occur alongside the more traditional concerns which focus on human
biological variation and the correlates of this variation.
Suggested reading
Boyd,
R. & Silk, J. 1997
How Humans Evolved, New York: Norton
[Well
presented and comprehensive introduction to biological anthropology.
Covers many of the new fields developing such as the study of primate
intelligence.]
Dunbar,
R.
1987 Primate
Social Systems, London: Croom Helm
[A
readable overview of examples and theories pertaining to primate
social behaviour.]
Gray,
A.
1993 World
Health and Disease, Milton Keynes: Open University Press
[A
simple and straightforward multi-disciplinary collection. Good sections
on health inequalities both internationally and within the UK.]
Harrison, G.A.,
Tanner, J., Pilbeam, D. &
Baker, P.
1988 Human
Biology: An Introduction to Human Evolution, Variation, Growth and
Adaptability (3rd edn), Oxford: Oxford University Press
[Standard
text for human biologists. Although ten years old, most of the articles
are still considered classics.]
Jones,
S. Martin, R. & Pilbeam, D.
1992 The
Cambridge Encyclopedia of Human Evolution, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press
[Comprehensive
coverage of evolutionary anthropology. Each entry is written by
a leader in the field.]
McElroy,
A. & Townsend, P.K.
1996 Medical
Anthropology in Ecological Perspective, Boulder, Colorado: Westview
Press
[Full
of examples and case studies of cross-cultural and ecological approaches
to the study of health and disease. Now into its third edition.]
Political Anthropology:
the study of
systems of power and social control in small scale societies and
communities
Ray
Abrahams University of Cambridge
and
Simon
Coleman University of Durham
In
the West, we are used to the idea of government within the framework
of the state and through the medium of specialised political and
legal institutions (eg parliament, police and law courts). Such
forms are now found world-wide, but this has not always been so,
and even today many peoples living within modern states rely to
a great extent on other mechanisms for the maintenance of law and
order. In societies where people live in closely-knit communities,
and rely heavily on each other for economic assistance, the local
maintenance of good social relations can be a matter of life or
death. Many ways of dealing with offences and of settling disputes
may be used. For example, in some societies community tensions are
released through the use of ritualised insults. In others, divination
is employed to discover the sources of conflict and aggression between
people.
Political
anthropology examines and compares these diverse systems of social
control. It also explores the power structures of societies, including
the extent of consensus and the patterns of equality or inequality
within them. It examines the ways in which leaders establish or
bolster their authority through tradition, force, persuasion, and
religion. It asks whether a society can have a legal system even
without formal courts and written laws. It is also interested in
the ways people resist excessive domination, both passively and
through Robin Hood-style banditry and other means.
One
key area of study for political anthropology has been the effect
of colonialism on subject peoples, and the ways in which western
legal systems have been adopted and also adapted to their needs
by non-western peoples. Another area of interest has been the role
of ceremonial and ritual, for instance in the installation ceremonies
of rulers, as a way of giving government an aura of legitimacy.
As
with other areas of anthropology, the study of diverse institutions
can also lead us to a broader-based understanding of our own and
other western social systems. Political anthropology has had interesting
insights to offer us on such issues as national identity, ethnic
conflict, the meaning of monarchy, and why people sometimes take
the law into their own hands.
Suggested reading
Abrahams,
R. 1996
'Vigilantism' in O. Harris (ed.) Inside and Outside the
Law, London: Routledge
[This
article explores the nature of vigilantism as one of a number of
forms of 'popular justice' on the margins of consensus in state
systems.]
Asad,
T.
1973 Anthropology
and the Colonial Encounter, London: Ithaca
[A
selection of essays re-examining the role of anthropology in a complex,
changing world. Authors examine the political role of the discipline
in the context of relations between western and non-western peoples.]
Hobsbawm,
E. 1959
Primitive Rebels, Manchester: Manchester University
Press
[A
lively survey of many forms of social movement from the past, including
bandits of the Robin-Hood type, peasant revolutionaries and pre-industrial
urban mobs. The focus is on western and southern Europe and peoples'
reactions to the introduction of capitalist economies.]
Leach,
E.
1977 Custom,
Law and Terrorist Violence, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press
[Two
lectures examining how anthropologists looked at law in the past
and asking whether the discipline has anything to say about contemporary
terroristic political violence.]
Lewellen,
T.
1983 Political
Anthropology: An Introduction,
Mass: Bergin & Garvey
[A
useful and accessible general introduction to the field of political
anthropology.]
Roberts,
S. 1979
Order and Dispute, Harmondsworth: Penguin
[An
accessible discussion of the ways in which order is maintained and
disputes settled in societies around the world.]
Religion and Belief
Systems: the
study of how people understand the world through their beliefs and
practices
Simon
Coleman University of Durham
People
living in the West tend to have a clear idea of what religion should
look like: it tends to take place in a building set aside for the
purpose (a church, synagogue, mosque, temple etc), revolves around
appeals to a higher, all-powerful deity and involves the articulation
of beliefs (often set down in texts) to which the general population
may or may not subscribe. Anthropologists have studied such religions,
but they have also examined contexts where religious practice looks
very different. In many cultures and societies, the idea of a single
God may not be present, and the notion of reading a sacred book
like the Koran or the Bible would seem very strange, not least because
writing and reading may not play any part in people's lives. Even
the western notion of 'belief' does not make much sense in contexts
where ideas about gods and spirits are taken for granted, and not
challenged by other faiths or the conclusions of the natural sciences.
Anthropologists
of religion are not concerned with discovering the truth or falsehood
of religion. They are more interested in how religious ideas express
a people's cosmology, ie notions of how the universe is organised
and the role of humans within the world. Many study rituals which
incorporate symbols, and note how these often help to bring
communities together in times of crisis or special points in the
calendar. The actions of religious specialists, whether these are
priests, prophets, shamans or spirit mediums are also examined.
In many societies, such specialists have important political and
economic as well as religious roles to play.
Suggested reading
Evans-Pritchard,
E.E.
1976 Witchcraft,
Oracles and Magic among the Azande (abridged version), Oxford:
Clarendon
[First
published in 1937, this classic in the anthropology of religion
was written by one of the most famous of all British anthropologists.
Evans-Pritchard studied the Azande, an African people, and showed
how their beliefs and practices, which at first seem irrational
to the western mind, have a logic and coherence of their own. Not
an easy read for a beginner, but this edition is shortened and has
a useful introduction.]
Lan,
D.
1985 Guns
and Rain. Guerrillas and Spirit Mediums in Zimbabwe, London:
James Currey
[Lan,
a playwright as well as a social anthropologist, describes the collaboration
between guerrillas and spirit mediums during the struggle for independence.
An exciting and fascinating read.]
Lewis,
I.M.
1989 Ecstatic
Religion. A Study of Shamanism and Possession (2nd edn), London:
Routledge
[A
clearly-written and wide-ranging book, which adopts a functionalist
approach. Lewis shows how shamanism and spirit possession round
the world can be linked to social and political factors.]
Lessa,
W. & Vogt, E.
1979 Reader
in Comparative Religion. An Anthropological Approach (4th edn),
New York: Harper and Row
[Contains
easily digestible extracts from important works in the anthropology
of religion, on such subjects as the functions of religion, ritual,
myth and shamanism.]
Lienhardt,
G. 1961
Divinity and Experience: The Religion of the Dinka,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
[An
accessible ethnography of the religion of an East African
people.]
Luhrmann,
T.
1989 Persuasions
of the Witch's Craft, Oxford: Blackwell
[Some
of this is difficult to understand for someone not used to the language
of anthropology, but much of it provides a readable discussion of
witchcraft in contemporary Britain. Luhrmann shows how anthropology
can be used to analyse religious ideas and identities in our own
society.]
Miller,
D. (ed.)
1993 Unwrapping Christmas, Oxford: Clarendon
[A
selection of papers of varying degrees of difficulty, showing how
anthropologists have analysed a seemingly familiar festival as it
is celebrated all around the world.]
Visual Anthropology
Marcus
Banks University of Oxford
A
common introduction to anthropology is through ethnographic film.
Readers may well be familiar with television series such as Disappearing
World and Under the Sun. These films are made by anthropologists
or professional film-makers and show life in non-European societies.
They are valuable in revealing a more rounded representation of
the issues that anthropologists normally investigate - particularly
with respect to ritual, music, dance and other areas where a purely
written description cannot convey the richness of the experience.
Teachers of anthropology have also found film to be valuable for
conveying a sense of the work that anthropologists actually do in
the field.
However,
visual anthropology is much more than ethnographic film. It encompasses
a much wider study of visual systems. Most anthropologists produce
visual representations in the course of their work (often photographs,
but also videos, maps, drawings and diagrams) and all societies
make visible aspects of their social life and their cultural understandings.
Visual anthropology is concerned with understanding the production
and consumption of all these forms. Visual anthropology clearly
overlaps with the anthropology of art, but also includes the study
of local photographic practice and increasingly the study of local
television and film production.
Suggested reading
Banks,
M.
1995 Visual
Research Methods [issue no. 11 of Social Research Update],
Department of Sociology, University of Surrey
[Brief
summary of the use of film, video and still photography in anthropological
and sociological research and analysis, also available on-line at
website: http://www.soc.surrey.ac.uk/sru/ SRU11/SRU11.html]
Banks,
M. & Morphy, Howard (eds)
1997 Rethinking
Visual Anthropology, New Haven: Yale University Press
[Recent
collection of essays on a wide range of visual systems, from computer
software notation to Balinese television; introductory essay provides
a comprehensive account of the history and current status of visual
anthropology.]
Dickey,
S. 1993
Cinema and the Urban Poor in South India, Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press
[Excellent
ethnographic account of one, very popular, visual system, covering
the Tamil film industry, the fan clubs, the film stars that become
politicians, and the films themselves.]
Edwards,
E. (ed.)
1992 Anthropology and Photography 1960-1920, New Haven &
London: Yale University Press in association with the Royal Anthropological
Institute
[A
strong and accessible collection of essays based on the RAI's extensive
photographic archive; a set of introductory and concluding essays
on the role and history of photography in anthropology frame twenty
studies of particular photographs or collections.]
Hockings,
P. (ed.)
1995 Principles
of Visual Anthropology (2nd edn), The Hague: Mouton
[First
published in 1975, this collection of essays marked a watershed
in establishing visual anthropology as a discipline; now rather
dated and almost exclusively focused on the production of film and
photographs by anthropologists, but still of some value.]
Rollwagen,
J. (ed.)
1988 Anthropological Film-making, Chur: Harwood Academic
Publishers
[Accessible,
if at times rather naive, collection of 'how I made a film' essays;
a useful reminder that ethnographic films do not come into existence
by accident.]
Ruby,
J.
1995 Secure
the Shadow: Death and Photography in America, Cambridge, Mass:
MIT Press
[Excellent
historical ethnography of one aspect of popular photography, beginning
with pre-photographic paintings of mourning and death, followed
by a chronological account of post-mortem and funeral assessment
of the motivation and use of these images; an on-line synopsis of
the book, plus further materials, is available at website: http://wsrv.clas.virginia.edu/~ds8s/jay.html]
Email about the Resource Guide to the authors:
Robert Simpson at Robert.Simpson@durham.co.uk
S.M. Coleman at S.M.Coleman@durham.ac.uk
Return to Resource Guide contents
page
|