The series of
DISAPPEARING WORLD
January 2000
from the INTERNATIONAL VIDEO SALES LIST
The Royal Anthropological Institute
50 Fitzroy Street
London W1T 5BT
United Kingdom
The holdings below are arranged in alphabetical
order by title, except when the titles begin with the words `The'
or `A', whereupon the cassettes are alphabetised by the word following
these two.
The video cassettes are available in PAL and NTSC world-wide
and cost £50.00 per programme.
ACROSS THE TRACKS: THE VLACH
GYPSIES OF HUNGARY
`Across the Tracks' is a gripping film for the
general viewer.... It is beautifully filmed in observational style
(lingering scenes of muddy courtyards) with enough subtitled interview
material to provide context. A. Sutherland
51 minutes Colour 1988
Filmmaker: John Blake
Anthropologist: Michael Stewart
Rom is the word that describes Vlach Gypsies, unassimilated
descendents of Gypsy slaves in Wallachia in Romania in the 19th
century. A larger group, the Romungro, are more obviously part of
Hungarian society: they speak Hungarian, not Romany. Romungros are
the people who play violins in restaurants; `true' Rom, the Vlach,
wouldn't dream of it. The total Gypsy population in Hungary forms
3% of the Hungarian population the same proportion as people of
Asian or Caribbean origin in Britain.
This Disappearing World film explores the Vlach Gypsies' position
in socialist Hungary through the eyes of three related families.
Maron and her husband Jozi work in conventional jobs where work
is compulsory: this is the fundamental first principle of the `official'
economy. Maron and Jozi use their income to improve their impoverished
lives. They are becoming more like the gazo the contemptuous Romany
term for all Hungarians, meaning `peasants'.
Jozi's first wife, Terez, and her husband Mokus try to realise their
dreams in a more Gypsy-like fashion. Terez scavenges in rubbish
bins for bread to fatten pigs which she hopes to sell for Mokus
to buy horses. Mokus reluctantly works in a factory but wants to
be a horse dealer like his brother-in-law Sera. He is disqualified
from work by a dubious disability, and instead buys and sells horses,
`turning money around, so that more comes to me.'
The market is central to the Gypsy economy, but is not seen as a
means of accumulating wealth. The market exists to circulate wealth,
to ensure money passes through as many hands as possible so that
all may benefit from it. If a Gypsy acquires money, he is expected
to celebrate with his friends, his `brothers'. Horses are like temporary
bank deposits, ready to be exchanged or cashed in when a `brother'
needs money.
This film provides an interesting view of the tensions between the
Hungarian state and the Gypsies, and of the complex contradictions
of the Gypsies' lives. It is recommended for classes in anthropology,
sociology, European studies, ethnicity, ecology, and political studies.
J. Okely, 1984. The Traveller-Gypsies. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge.
M. Stewart, 1989. `True Speech'. Man N.S. Vol. 24,
pp. 79101.
A. Sutherland, 1975. Gypsies: The Hidden Americans.
Tavistock, London.
A. Sutherland, 1989. `Across the Tracks: The Vlach Gypsies
of Hungary'. Anthropology Today, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp.
2021.
THE BASQUES OF SANTAZI
52 minutes Colour 1987
Filmmaker: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: Sandra Ott
In her book `The Circle of Mountains' Sandra Ott
provided a fascinating analysis of social reciprocity.... The film
highlights the village's contemporary dilemmas and thereby complements
rather than visualises the arguments in Ott's published ethnography....
The approach is to be applauded since the book and the film now
make excellent companion pieces that can usefully be employed in
any course on European ethnography. William Douglass
This film follows the lives over one year, shot during three intervals,
of two Basque shepherding families who live in Santazi, a village
in the foothills of the French Pyrenees. The film is the only Disappearing
World film made in western Europe and it focuses on the continuity
and change in the community.
Change has come to the village of Santazi in recent years along
the avenues of introduced roads and improved communication systems
with the outside world. The effects stretch from people's relationship
with the Catholic religion to inheritance customs. Television has
of course also entered these villagers' homes. The traditional life
of shepherding is also changing amidst the conflict of interest
between those who have formed a syndicated in an effort to maintain
the viability of shepherding and the sons who have taken jobs as
linemen for the electricity company. This film shows the rationality
behind the choice the villagers are making.
This film is recommended for courses in anthropology, sociology,
culture change, and European communities.
W. Douglass, 1987. Review of the film. Anthropology
Today, Vol. 3, No. 5 pp. 1718.
S. Ott, 1981. The Circle of Mountains. Oxford
University Press, Oxford.
S. Ybarrola, 1988. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 90, pp. 104546.
A CLEARING IN THE JUNGLE
38 minutes Colour
Director: Charlie Nairn
Anthropologist: Jean-Paul Dumont
In common with many other Indian groups in South America,
the culture of the Panare Indians of Venezuela is threatened by
their almost daily contact with neighbouring creoles, Spanish-speaking
peasants. However, in spite of nearly fifty years of interaction,
their culture has remained distinctively Indian.
The film focuses on activities of their daily life, such as making
cassava, preparing blow-darts, hunting and gathering. The
Indians strongly resented the presence of the camera-crew;
indeed, as Dumont points out early in the film, they were loath
to reveal details of their belief-system even to him, although he
had been living with them for eighteen months.
This was the first and the shortest of the films in the Disappearing
World series. Although useful and interesting, it is relatively
superficial and its commentary contains some anthropological oddities:
it cannot be compared with the much more sophisticated films made
later in the series.
J.-P. Dumont, 1976. Under the Rainbow: Nature and
Supernature among Panare. University of Texas Press, Austin.
J.-P. Dumont, 1979. The Headman and I: Ambiguity
and Ambivalence in the Fieldworking Experience. University
of Texas Press, Austin.
THE DERVISHES OF KURDISTAN
52 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Anthropologists: Ali Bulookbashi and André Singer
A community of Kurds resident in Iran on the border
with Iraq forms the subject of this film. Many of the inhabitants
of the community are refugees from Kurdish areas of Iraq and the
villagers are Qadiri Dervishes followers of an ecstatic mystical
cult of Islam. The unusual manifestations of the Qadiri Dervish
faith are explored in this film, both in the context of religious
ceremonies and everyday life, with the main focus on the spiritual
and temporal power wielded by their leader, Sheikh Hussein.
For the Durvishes, Hussein is the direct representative of Allah
and, therefore, by serving the Sheikh they are also serving God.
In rituals presided over by him they have the power to carry out
acts which would normally be harmful, such as having electricity
passed through their bodies, eating glass, handling poisonous snakes
and skewering their faces. The film includes interviews, not
only with members of the cult, but also with the local mullah (representative
of orthodox Islam), in an attempt to explore the difference between
those two manifestations of the same faith.
The film is visually compelling, especially the sequences showing
religious celebration and ceremony.
F. Barth, 1953. Principles of Social Organisation in South
Kurdistan. Universitetets Etnografiske Museum Bulletin
No. 7, Oslo.
A. Singer, 1973. `Dervishes'. In T. Stacey (editorial
director) Peoples of the World, Vol. 15, Western and Central
Asia, Tom Stacey and Europa Verlag, [London.]
A. Singer, 1974. `The Dervishes of Kurdistan'. Asian
Affairs, Vol. 61, Part 2, pp. 179182.
M. Van Bruinessen, 1978. Agha, Shaikh and State.
On the Social and Political Organization of Kurdistan.
Utrecht.
EMBERA THE END OF THE ROAD
50 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Anthropologist: Ariane Deluz
The way of life of the 10,000 Embera Indians who live
in the Choco region of Colombia, South American, is threatened by
the encroachments of Negro Libres (descendants of freed slaves)
and by the expansion of the Pan-American highway which cuts through
their land.
The film's main concern is to show the effects of interaction between
the Embera river dwellers and two groups of outsiders: the Libres
with whom they trade, and the local Catholic mission which administers
education, religion and civil justice. Although the Embera
are exploited by the Libres (who, for example, sell them hunting
dogs at very high prices) both groups are poor and largely without
rights in Colombian society. In an interview, the Embera explain
to the anthropologist that they want protection from the physical
attacks of the Libres and legal rights over the land which they
have inhabited for many years. Sequences such as this bring
out the Embera's plight: they are caught between the bulldozers
and the banknotes of the Libres. We are shown the material
culture and way of life of the Indians (canoe building, pot making,
hunting, curing rituals) but not in a romanticised way, and the
polemical organisation of the film allows the ethnographic details
of the life of these river Indians to be placed in a wide social
and economic context.
A. Deluz, 1975. `L'initiation d'un chamane Embera'.
Bulletin de la Societe des Americanistes, No. 39, pp.511.
L.C. Faron, 1962. `Marriage, Residence and Domestic Group
among Panamanian Choco'. Ethnology, Vol. 1, pp. 1338.
G. Reichel-Dolmatoff, 1960. `Notas Etnograficas sobre los
Indios del Choco'. Revista Colombiana de Antropologia,
IX, pp.73158.
G. Stipek, Jr., 1974. `The Kindred as a Corporate Group:
the Embera Example'. Presented at 73rd Annual Meeting of American
Anthropological Association, Mexico.
THE ESKIMOS OF POND INLET
52 minutes Colour
Director: Michael Grigsby
Anthropologist: Hugh Brody
For the Eskimos of Pond Inlet a new village in
North Baffin Island in which they have been settled by the Canadian
Government the life of the semi-nomadic hunter has given way to
that of wage-labourer, in what appears as a pre-fabricated `township'.
Although hunting provides an important supplement to the Eskimos'
income, it is now a part-time activity, and since 1975 (ten years
after the start of the government's housing programme) nobody has
lived all year round in hunting camps. For the older inhabitants
of Pond Inlet, the old way of life is still vivid (in 1935 only
37 Eskimos lived in the village) and their reminiscences and recollections
form part of a powerful statement about the present situation.
These statements take the form of monologues, or comments addressed
to friends and family about the effects of fifty years of contact
with whites.
Apart from these `interviews' with the Eskimos, the film accompanies
one family grandfather, father, mother and children as they
go out hunting seals and jigging for fish. The visual contrast
between the splendours of the open spaces of snow and water and
the township of Pond Inlet is a startling one which reinforces the
Eskimos' statements. We also see one member of this family
selling seal skins in a trade store, and captioned information is
given about the cost of maintaining the hunter's equipment and what
he can expect to earn in any one year.
The material was filmed during a seven week period in June and July
1975. A sophisticated `observational' style is used, with
long takes, few pans, no commentary or formal interviews and full
subtitling. Caption cards are used to good effect, conveying
necessary information without intruding on the narrative.
These `technical' factors have important consequences for the film's
anthropological value, not least because one of the aims was to
enable the Eskimos to `speak for themselves'. Although it
would be naive to suggest that the `people's voice' manages to override
the exigencies of making such a film for a 52 minute television
slot, the Eskimos did have a say in the making of the film, and
one of them was also involved in the editing. The striking
oratorical style of the Eskimos awakens the viewer to the point
that in this film they are addressing the Whites, voicing their
distrust, having overcome the fear with which they first encountered
these `visitors' to the people's land.
H. Brody, 1975. The People's Land: Eskimos and Whites
in the Eastern Arctic. Penguin, Harmondsworth.
H. Brody, 1975. `Seeming to be Real: Disappearing
World and the Film in Pond Inlet', Cambridge Anthropology,
Special Issue on Ethnographic Film, pp.2231.
D. Riches, 1976. Review of the film. RAIN,
13, p.7.
IN SEARCH OF COOL GROUND: THE MURSI TRILOGY
19741985 Colour
Filmmaker Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: David Turton
What made this trilogy special was that, unlike
most television reportage, it had a temporal dimension. That is
to say, it offered not a brutal, intrusive and uncomprehending snapshot,
but a sympathetic, well-informed and thoughtful history of ten difficult
years in the life of a tribe. Its insight derived from an anthropologist,
David Turton, who has been studying the Mursi for years and who
was able to provide the absolutely essential explanations of the
mysterious events filmed by the Granada crew. This is the kind of
illumination which is often provided by books or by personal experience,
but almost never by television. John Naughton
This is a trilogy about aspects of the culture of two groups of
people, the Kwegu and the Mursi, in Ethiopia. The titles are:
-
-
- THE MURSI
-
(see below)
- THE KWEGU
-
(see below)
- THE MIGRANTS
-
(see below)
J. Naughton, 1985. Review of the trilogy. The Listener
(London), 24 October.
W. Shack, 1987. Review of the trilogy. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 89, pp. 78081.
KATARAGAMA: A GOD FOR ALL SEASONS
52 minutes Colour
Director: Charlie Nairn
Anthropologist: Gananath Obeyesekere
In ever-increasing numbers Sinhalese of all religions
(Muslims, Christians and Buddhists) are turning to Kataragama, an
ancient Hindu God, at times of trouble and desperation. Once
a year pilgrims make the journey to Kataragama's shrine in southeast
Sri Lanka (Ceylon) to fulfil vows by performing acts of penance
and worship in payment for a favour received. Kataragama is
called on to help with a wide range of problems (unemployment, sickness,
examinations, personal relationships) and is appealed to by people
of all social backgrounds, notably the growing middle class and
urban dwellers.
A good third of the film is concerned with the annual festival,
showing the often gruesome and sensational acts which the pilgrims
perform including fire-walking, and the piercing of body and tongue
with needles all acts designed to obtain forgiveness and grace.
One man is suspended from hooks in his back a self-torture undertaken
with apparent joy by a man who, like many others that perform such
acts, feels himself (after a time) to be possessed by the God's
spirit.
These rather sensational acts are interwoven with the story of a
peasant family whose son has disappeared, leading them eventually
to seek help from Kataragama. The unfolding of this personal
drama (with reconstruction of early episodes, and voice-over to
detail their thoughts and feelings) forms the context for the events
we see at the festival. The effect of the interweaving of
these two `stories' is to place the otherwise purely exotic spectacle
of the pilgrims' acts of penance within a universally understandable
social context that of the despair of a family whose young son
is lost. The unplanned return of the boy, apparently in response
to the family's appeal to Kataragama, provides a dramatic and moving
finale to a film which has been compared in some respects to the
great Italian neo-realist films. Clearly this film is an important
one both for anthropologists and those concerned with ethnographic
film per se.
R. Gombrich, 1974. Review of the film. RAIN,
3, pp.89.
G. Obeyesekere, 1977. `Social Change and the Deities:
Rise of the Kataragama Cult in Modern Sri Lanka'. Man, Vol.
12, Nos.3/4. pp.377396.
THE KAWELKA: ONGKA'S BIG MOKA
52 minutes Colour
Director: Charlie Nairn
Anthropologists: Andrew and Marilyn Strathern
Ongka is a charismatic big-man of the Kawelka tribe
who live scattered in the Western highlands, north of Mount Hagen,
in New Guinea. The film focuses on the motivations and efforts
involved in organising a big ceremonial gift-exchange or moka
planned to take place sometime in 1974. Ongka has spent nearly
five years preparing for this ceremonial exchange, using all his
big-man skills of oratory and persuasion in order to try to assemble
what he hopes will be a huge gift of 600 pigs, some cows, some cassowaries,
a motorcycle, a truck and £5,500 in cash. As an example of
the big-man familiar from written texts, Ongka is memorable, and
the film manages to convey through this main character the importance
of pigs, of exchange and of prestige in the life of these Highlanders.
The film-crew never in fact managed to film the big moka,
as the conspiratorial and complex manoeuvres involved in setting
the date thwarted their plans. But we are shown Ongka replacing
tee-shirt and shorts with his ceremonial feathers and setting off
to a little moka where he collects pigs he `invested' with
his wife's father. The interview with Ongka's wife raises
the issue of the sexual division of labour and the importance of
the wife's labour in pig-rearing and moka preparation, as
well as the role of women in the establishment of a big-man.
As a teaching aid to complement the written material (listed below)
this film is highly effective.
J. Leach, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN, 7, pp.78.
See reply by A. Strathern in RAIN, 8, 1975, pp.1617.
A. Strathern, 1971. The Rope of Moka. Cambridge
University Press.
A. Strathern, 1979. Ongka: A Self Account by a New
Guinea Big-Man. Duckworth, London.
THE KAYAPO
51 minutes Colour 1987
Filmmaker: Michael Beckham
Anthropologist: Terence Turner
Professor Terry Turner explained this truly extraordinary
situation in a lucid, intelligent and unpatronizing commentary....
Mike Beckham directed this splendid film with great pace. The result
is an important and accurate picture of two contrasting essays in
acculturation. It was also gripping television for a prime-time
audience. J. Hemming
This film focuses on the conflicts and determination of a group
of people trying to survive and maintain their ethnic identity in
the face of almost overpowering odds. The film contrasts the
reactions of two groups of Kayapo to outside influence. The
Kapot have opposed contact and resisted both non-indigenous Brazilian
settlers and gold miners. The Gorotire, by contrast, were
invaded by gold miners who strip-mined their land and polluted their
rivers. The miners paid the Gorotire very little for the destruction
until 1985 when the Gorotire forced the miners to raise the commission
by 5% when 200 warriors seized the airstrip. This commission
amounts to two million dollars per year for the tribe and the tribe
is learning to cope with the money, both with the problems it brings
and the power it gives. They have trained several of their
number to deal effectively with the outside world on behalf of the
rest of the tribe and they now run a plane (and hire a pilot) to
patrol their land against intruders.
The Kapot, in their own way, are also trying to assert their identity
and independence. This portion of the film shows the Kapot
in the traditional activities of building and dismantling a hunting
camp. The hunters returning with the tortoises they have caught
are a particularly impressive sight. The now famous Chief
Rop-ni is featured as a leader of the Kapot and he states eloquently
his opposition to the Gorotire's acceptance of the gold miners.
Despite their adherence to tradition, however, the Kapot use modern
technology video, radios, etc. to protect their interests and
record their rituals.
This is a political film and would be excellent for courses in anthropology,
Latin American studies, ecology, development, and international
politics.
J. Hemming, 1987. Review of the film. Anthropology Today,
Vol. 3, No. 4, p. 20.
P. Riviere 1989. Review of the film in Anthropology Today,
Vol. 2, No. 2, pp. 21315.
THE KAYAPO·OUT OF THE FOREST
51 minutes Colour
Filmmaker: Michael Beckham
Anthropologist: Terence Turner
Early in 1989 the Kayapo rallied other Brazilian Indians
to attend a reunification of the tribes at Altamira·the proposed
site of a massive hydro-electric dam, that will flood large parts
of the Xingu valley. The gathering also served as a media event
as the Kayapo and their allies demonstrated their case to the assembled
international press. The film focuses on the Kayapo's ability to
manipulate the media, including Chief Rop-ni stage-managing his
entrance to arrive with the pop star Sting. However, much of the
power of this film, made for Granada Television's Disappearing World
series, comes from the tensions that revolve around the intricate
planning behind the Altamira meeting. A Kayapo warrior, Pakayan,
brings together previously hostile and warring factions in a common
cause. Tension mounts when, only days before the conference, he
is rushed to hospital for major surgery, and must force himself
from his hospital bed to ensure the survival of the alliance he
has carved.
V. Lea, 1986. Nomes e Nekrets Kayapó: Uma Concepcao
de Rigueza. PhD thesis (3 vols.), Federal University of Rio
de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro
S. Nugent, 1989. Review of the film in Anthropology Today
Vol. 5, No. 5, pp. 1819.
D. Posney, 1988. `Kayapo Indian Natural Resource Management'.
In C. Padoch and J. Denselo (eds.) Peoples of the Rainforest.
University of California Press. pp. 8990.
T. Turner, 1978. `The Kayapo of Central Brazil'. In
A. Sutherland (ed.) Face Values. BBC Publications,
London. pp. 245279. [`The Kayapo of Central Brazil'
and `The Social Skin' are written for a general audience, the former
dealing with social and political structure and the latter with
social values and the cultural constitution of the person (thus
touching on many of the same themes as the Jaguar film). For
those interested in pushing further with the ideas raised in the
Jaguar film, see T. Turner, 1980 `Le Dénicheur d'Oiseaux en Contexte',
Anthropologie et Sociétés, Vol. 4, No. 3, pp. 85115, and articles
by Gustaaf Verswijver.]
T. Turner, 1979. `The Gê and Bororo Societies as Dialectical
Systems'. In D. Maybury-Lewis (ed.) Dialectical Societies.
Harvard University Press.
T. Turner, 1979. `Kinship, Household and Community Structure
among the Kayapo'. ibid.
T. Turner, 1980. `The Social Skin'. In J. Cherfas (ed.)
Not Work Alone. London.
T. Turner, 1985. `Animal Symbolism, Totemism and the Structure
of Myth'. In P. Urton (ed.) Animals, Myths and Metaphor
in South America. University of Uta Press. pp. 49107.
T. Turner, 1990. `Visual Media, Cultural Politics, and Anthropological
Practice. Some Implications of Recent Uses of Film and Video
among the Kayapo of Brazil'. C.V.A. Review, Spring
1990, pp. 813. [In this article Turner discusses the context
in which The Kayapo and The Kayapo Out of the Forest
were made.]
L. Vidal, 1977. Morte a Vida numa Sociedade Indigena Brasileira.
Ed. Hucitec, Sao Paolo.
THE KAZAKHS OF CHINA
50 minutes Colour 1983
Filmmaker: André Singer
Anthropologist: Shirin Akiner
The Kazakhs of Xinjiang (Sinkiang) are one of the
fifty-five national minorities that now live within the borders
of the People's Republic of China. The policy of the Chinese Communist
Party toward these people has been one of Sinofication, a neutralization
of `reactionary' local leaders and an alliance of Han Chinese with
the indigenous culture. Xinjiang is a particularly sensitive area
for the Chinese because of the traditional ties of the Kazakh with
the Soviet Union. In 1962, some 50,000 Kazakhs and other non-Han
peoples sought refuge in the Kazakh Soviet Socialist Republic. Since
then, the Sino-Soviet border has been closed, and until recently
the entire area was off-limits to non-Chinese outsiders. This film
offers unique ethnographic material about the Kazakh, as well as
about Chinese policies in the years following the Cultural Revolution.
The film follows the movement of the family of Abdul Gair, illustrated
the cycles and tensions of present day Kazakhs, mixes detail of
their traditional life as herders with suggestion of the effect
of Chinese rule. The Chinese government allowed the filmmakers freedom
to choose the subjects and people for the interviews and action
sequences. Because of this, the film expresses, to a great extent,
the view of the filmmaker, not of the Chinese government. Against
a background of the Tienshan Mountains, the Kazakhs are shown branding
yaks, milking mares, drinking kumis (fermented mare's milk), making
their yearly move from winter to summer quarters, and setting up
their felt-covered summer tents. Then, through the trip of Ahmed
the production team leader to the brigade headquarters, the film
portrays the relations between Kazakh and Han, showing the brigade's
authority. Rather than livestock, formerly a mark of wealth being
owned for individual profit, production and gain is now controlled
by the brigade leaders. Women are given more freedom within the
community. Kazakh children now have an opportunity for education
in the Kazakh language, but the teaching is largely Party doctrine;
they have health care, but this again is Chinese. Yet, despite pre-1977
restrictions on local religion and nomadic culture, and although
Abdul Gair is himself a Party member, the Chinese do not, as yet,
control the Kazakh. The Kazakh have retained their horses, not only
as wealth, but as a means of freedom.
Here, as in other cultures where a strong centralized government
controls a minority, the continued cultural independence of the
Kazakh is an open question. The Chinese policy is currently to move
as many Han as possible from the overcrowded central areas of China
to the less populated border areas such as Xinjiang. This film gives
an understanding, not only of a Kazakh society, but also insights
into current change, of the conflicts of domination and independence.
S. Akiner, 1984. Islamic Peoples of the Soviet Union.
Kegan Paul International, London.
E. Bacon, 1966. Central Asians under Russian Rule: A Study in
Culture Change. Cornell University Press, Ithaca N.Y.
Fei Hsiao-tung, 1981. Towards a People's Anthropology.
New World Press, Beijing.
S. Feuchtwang, 1983. Review of the film. RAIN, No.
57, p. 10.
A.E. Hudson, 1938. Kazak Social Structure. Yale University
Press, New Haven.
L. Krader, 1966. Peoples of Central Asia. Uralic and
Altaic Series, Vol. 26, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana.
G. Moseley, 1966. A Sino-Soviet Cultural Frontier: The
Ili Kazakh Autonomous Chou. East Asian Research Center,
Cambridge, Mass.
H.G. Schwarz, 1984. The Minorities of Northern China.
Center for East Asian Studies, Western Washington University, Bellingham,
Washington. [Bibliography mostly in Chinese; relevant pages for
Kazakhs of China pp. 1726 and pp. 25963.]
A. Singer with L. Woodhead, 1988. Disappearing World: Television
and Anthropology. Granada Television Ltd., Boxtree.
THE KIRGHIZ OF AFGHANISTAN
51 minutes Colour
Director: Charlie Nairn
Anthropologist: Nazif Shahrani
The Kirghiz of Afghanistan are a group of some 2,000
pastoralists living on a bleak mountain plateau in a narrow isthmus
of land between the borders of the Soviet Union and China.
For nine months of the year heavy snows cover the ground, which
was formerly used only by the Kirghiz for their summer pastures
before the borders were closed, virtually terminating the contact
of this group with other Kirghiz communities. Although the
film shows dramatically the ten-day journey which lowland traders
must make to reach this remote people, as well as scenes of a Kirghiz
wedding and the traditional Central Asian sport of `buzkashi'
demonstrating the horse-riding skills of the people there is very
little about the pastoral economy and society of the ordinary Kirghiz.
The main reason for this is that the film focuses on the remarkable
wealth and authority of their leader the Khan by far the wealthiest
pastoralist on the plateau. Ninety-five Kirghiz families work
for him as shepherds and herders. The film's principal concern
is to show the way in which the Khan wields his power (using interviews
with him and illustrative scenes) which thus turns The Kirghiz into
a study of oppressive paternalism in this remote corner of the world.
There is, however, some disagreement over the interpretation of
the Khan's role (see correspondence in RAIN listed below).
R. Dor, 1975. Contribution à l étude des Kirghiz du Pamir
Afghan. Publication Orientalistes de France, Paris.
R. Dor and C. Naumann, 1978. Die Kirghisen des Afghanischen
Pamir. Graz, Austria.
N. Shahrani, 1976. `Kirghiz Pastoralists of the Afghan Pamirs',
Folk, Vol. 18, pp. 129143.
N. Shahrani, 1979. The Kirghiz and Wakhi of Afghanistan.
University of Washington Press, Seattle.
A. Singer, 1976. `Problems of Pastoralism in the Afghan Pamirs'.
Asian Affairs, Vol. 63, Pt. 2, pp. 156160.
N. Tapper, 1976. Review of the film. RAIN, 13,
p.6. See also correspondence in RAIN, 16, pp.1011.
THE KWEGU
`The Kwegu' is an entirely tasteful and dignified
presentation of the harsh realities of subsistence living, and it
may help us understand how, even in stateless societies, dominated
groups come to accept their domination as part of the natural order.
A. Southall
50 minutes Colour 1982
Filmmaker: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: David Turton
The Kwegu are hunters and cultivators who live along
the banks of the River Omo in Southwestern Ethiopia. They are experts
on the river, manipulating their dugout canoes through a swift current
where falling overboard could mean delivery into the jaws of a crocodile.
The Mursi are cattle herders and cultivators who live with the Kwegu
for several months of the year. This film is about the relationship
between these two groups of people.
The Mursi number about 5,000 and the Kwegu about 500. Both groups
cultivate flood land along the Omo during the dry season, when the
Mursi may also bring their cattle to the river. But the Kwegu keep
themselves separate from the Mursi; they speak their own language
among themselves, although they are bilingual and communicate with
the Mursi only in Mursi. When the Mursi and Kwegu share a village,
the Kwegu houses usually form a separate cluster.
When a Kwegu marries, a vital part of the bridewealth is livestock.
But since the Kwegu do not keep cattle, a system of exchange has
developed whereby the Kwegu perform services in exchange for Mursi
cattle. In addition to providing bridewealth cattle, the Mursi patron
protects `his' Kwegu from other Mursi and acts on his behalf in
bridewealth negotiations. In return the Kwegu provides his patron
with honey and game meat and is available to ferry him and his family
across the Omo when needed. This is a vital economic service, since
the Mursi cultivate on both banks of the river and yet do not, unlike
the Kwegu, live at the Omo all the year round. The Kwegu are therefore
`guardians' of the canoes as well as ferrymen.
There is some debate about the nature of the Mursi-Kwegu relationship.
The anthropologist advisor for the film, David Turton, sees the
relationship as one of domination. The Mursi depend economically
on the Kwegu more than the Kwegu do on them, and yet the Kwegu see
themselves as dependent, in a different, more extreme sense, on
the Mursi: they cannot marry without the aid of Mursi patron. The
Mursi exploit the economic services of the Kwegu through their control
of Kwegu marriage. Jean Lydall, in her review of the film in RAIN
(June 1982), suggests another interpretation for the exchange of
services. She wonders if indeed the Kwegu are not making the Mursi
`pay through the nose´ for the services they require. This film
suggests that far from being second-class citizens, the Kwegu are
sharp manipulators who have acquired protection and material wealth
by making their services indispensable to the Mursi. Turton defended
his interpretation in a reply to Lydall (RAIN, No. 51, pp. 1012)
and has more recently provided a more detailed description and analysis
of the Mursi-Kwegu relationship, following the same argument as
developed in the film but including much additional ethnographic
information (Turton, 1986). The Kwegu won the Grand Prix du Festival
at the Festival International du Film de Grand Reportage in Paris.
This film is the second part of a trilogy, In Search of Cool
Ground (see entry). The film is particularly recommended for
courses in anthropology, African studies, patronclient relationships,
ethnicity and multi-cultural studies.
D..J.J. Brown, 1983. `The Kwegu' (letter). RAIN, No.
55, p. 12.
J. Lydall, 1982. Review of the film. RAIN, No. 50,
pp. 2224.
A. Singer with L. Woodhead, 1988. Disappearing World: Television
and Anthropology. Granada Television Ltd., Boxtree.
A. Southall, 1984. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 86, pp. 51213.
D. Turton, 1977. `Response to Drought: The Mursi of Southwest
Ethiopia'. In J.P. Garlick and R.W.J. Keay (eds.) Human Ecology
in the Tropics. Taylor and Francis, London. (Reprinted in Disasters,
Vol. 1, No. 4, 1977).
D. Turton, 1982. `The Kwegu' (letter). RAIN, No. 51, pp.
1012.
D. Turton, 1986. `A Problem of Domination at the Periphery:
The Kwegu and the Mursi'. In W. James and D. Donham (eds.) The
Southern Marches of Imperial Ethiopia: Essays in History and Social
Anthropology. Cambridge University Press.
L. Woodhead, 1987. A Box Full of Spirits: Adventures of a Film
Maker in Africa. Heinemann, London.
THE LAST OF THE CUIVA
68 minutes Colour 1987
Director: Brian Moser
Anthropologist: Bernard Arcand
The film focuses on recent changes in the culture
and society of the Cuiva, hunters and gatherers in a remote forest
region of south-eastern Colombia, brought about through contact
with Colombian settlers. Two groups of Cuiva are shown:
one is relatively isolated, while the other has had extensive contacts
with the settlers. The first group live a nomadic life moving
frequently: the men hunt and fish, the women gather.
The second group has been drawn into the Colombian economy, working
occasionally for the ranchers to earn money to buy trade goods.
The film also usefully includes interviews with white ranchers,
showing their racist attitudes to the Indians, whom in the past
they feared and on whose land they are now continually encroaching.
The basic incompatibility between the economic systems of the Cuiva
(based on communal distribution of food, gift-giving and receiving),
and that of the settlers who attempt to survive within the world-capitalist
market, is startlingly illustrated. Unlike later films in
the series, The Last of the Cuiva relies on a moving commentary
recorded during filming by the French-Canadian anthropologist, Bernard
Arcand, who emphasises that the traditional way of life of the Cuiva
(whom he describes, following Sahlins, as exemplifying the `original
affluent society') will be seriously damaged by these contacts with
whites. Rather than giving a more conventional anthropological
description, Arcand's commentary is a humanist plea for the survival
of hunter-gatherer groups, and carries an implicit criticism of
western lifestyles.
B. Arcand, 1972. The Urgent Situation of the Cuiva Indians
of Colombia, Document No. 7, International Work Group for Indigenous
Affairs, Copenhagen. (Available from Survival International,
36 Craven Street, London WC2.)
B. Arcand, 1979. `The Cuiva Band'. In G. A. Smith and
D.H. Turner (eds.), Challenging Anthropology: A Critical
Introduction to Social and Cultural Anthropology. McGraw
Hill, Toronto.
P. and D. Maybury-Lewis, 1974. Review of the film. American
Anthropologist, Vol. 76, pp.487489.
THE LAU OF MALAITA
Pierre Miranda and a team from Granada Television
have made a fine film exploring the trouble realities of the people
of the lagoon in the 1980s. B. Shore
51 minutes Colour 1987
Filmmaker: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: Pierre Maranda
This film focuses on the people of Lau lagoon in the
Solomon Islands who live on artificial islands near the island of
Malaita. These islands are built of coral rubble and the people
moved to them in an attempt to escape the dangers of malaria and
enemies, and to find better fishing.
The film focuses on change and conflict. The concept of `custom'
is vital to the islanders' identity, yet this is being eroded, particularly
by Christian missionaries. The conflict between Christian and Pagan
now pervades daily life, creating divisions in families and eroding
knowledge of traditional life. Two `custom' priests recently committed
ritual suicide, one by swimming under a canoe containing women and
the other by deliberately making a mistake in a ceremony. Within
weeks, both priests physically died.
The despair in the ability of `custom' to continue that these priests
must have felt is presented visually throughout the film. Few of
the islanders remember more than a fraction of the hundreds of traditional
spirits and the young are turning more and more to the traditions
and commodities of Western culture. This theme is a common one makes
it no less powerful or relevant.
Spurred by the presence of the Disappearing World camera crew, the
islanders built a house in which to store their traditional and
ritual objects. A commendable act of preservation on the part of
the islanders, but at the same time the implications of their act
are saddening. They are taking their ritual things out of the sphere
of living, daily tradition and placing them in the realm of objective
history.
The Lau is recommended for courses in anthropology, sociology,
development, culture change, Melanesia, religion, and ecology.
B. Burt, 1988. Review of the film in Visual Anthropology
Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 48283.
C. E. Fox, 1974. Lau Dictionary with English Index.
Australian National University Press, Canberra.
P. Gathercole, 1987. Review of the film. Anthropology Today,
Vol. 3, No. 4, p. 20.
W.G. Ivens, 1930. The Island Builders of the Pacific.
Lippincott, Philadelphia.
E.K. Maranda, 1978. `The Averted Gift: The Lau Myth
of the Seeker of Exchange'. Yearbook of Symbolic Anthropology,
Vol. 1, pp. 3750.
P. Maranda, 1985. `Un Ici Ailleurs'. In S. Genest (ed.)
La Passion de l'Echange, pp. 1019. G. Morin, Chicoutimi.
P. Maranda, 1987. Correspondence on the film. Anthropology
Today, Vol. 3, No. 6, p. 24.
P. Maranda, forthcoming. Mythe, Métaphore et Métamorphose:
Les Lao de Malaita.
P. Maranda and E.K. Maranda, 1970. `Le Crâne et l'Utérus:
Deux Théorèmes Nord-Malaitains'. In J. Pouillon and P. Maranda
(eds.) Echanges et Communications, pp. 82961. Mouton,
Paris and The Hague.
B. Shore, 1989. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 91, pp. 2756.
MASAI MANHOOD
53 minutes Colour
Director: Chris Curling
Anthropologist: Melissa Llewelyn-Davies
This film was made after Masai Women and in
the same area. Together the two films provide a vivid view
of Masai men and women and their place in Masai society.
The Masai are pastoral nomads in the East African rift valley with
a social system which differentiates sharply between men and women
and between age-sets. A particularly crucial distinction is
made between men who are moran (`warriors') and more senior
men classed as elders. After circumcision men live in the
forest on the fringes of Masai society as moran debarred
from marriage and excluded from crucial decision-making procedures.
The film is focused on the life of the moran and on the dramatic
eunoto ceremony which marks the important transition from
warriorhood to full social maturity and the responsibilities of
elderhood. The moran are given an opportunity in the
film to talk about warriorhood and they sensitively strive to explain
their ideals to the anthropologist. Their words are effectively
translated in sub-titles. There is much valuable information
in the film on the events leading up to the eunoto ceremony
including a fascinating sequence on the joking abuse directed
by the moran at their mothers and on the ritual procedures
involved in the rite de passage itself.
This may well be the last eunoto ceremony ever to be held
as the pressures on the Masai to change their way of life are increasingly
strong, and the film is important for the way in which it conveys
the drama of the events and their significance both for the participants
and for the Masai social system.
H. A. Fosbrooke, 1948. `An Administrative Survey of the Masai
Social System'. Tanganyika Notes and Records, 26, pp.
150.
G.W.B. Huntingford (ed.), 1972. `Masai Kenya, Tanzania'.
In T. Stacey (editorial director), Peoples of the World,
Vol. 2, Africa from the Sahara to the Zambezi. Tom
Stacey and Europa Verlag, [London].
J. La Fontaine, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN,
9, p.6.
M. Llewelyn-Davies, 1978. `Two Contexts of Solidarity amongst
Pastoral Masai Women'. In P. Caplan and J. Bujra (eds.), Women
United, Women Divided. Tavistock, London.
M. Sharman, 1979. People of the Plains. Evans Brothers
Ltd., London. (A 32-page booklet on the Masai, in the series
Kenya's People, intended for use in schools.)
P. Spencer, 1976. `Opposing Streams and the Gerontocratic
Ladder: Two Models of Age Organisation in East Africa'. Man,
Vol. 11, No. 2, pp. 153175.
P. Spencer, 1977. Age and the Paternal Yoke among the Masai
(an unpublished manuscript deposited by Dr. Spencer in the Library
of the Museum of Mankind).
R. Waller, 1976. `The Masai and the British 18951905'.
Journal of African History, pp. 529553.
For rich and detailed material on a similar society see:
P. Spencer, 1965. The Samburu: A Study of Gerontocracy
in a Nomadic Tribe. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
MASAI WOMEN
53 minutes Colour
Director: Chris Curling
Anthropologist: Melissa Llewelyn-Davies
The Masai are cattle herders living in the East African
rift valley: they grow no crops and are proud of being a non-agricultural
people. Cattle are the all-important source of wealth and
social status, and Masai love their cattle, composing poems to them.
However, it is the men who have exclusive control over rights to
cattle, and women are dependent, throughout their lives, on a man
father, husband or son for rights of access to property.
A woman's status as `daughter', `wife' or `mother' is therefore
crucial and this film examines with depth and sensitivity the social
construction of womanhood in Masai society, concentrating upon women's
attitudes to their own lives.
The film details a series of events in women's lives, from their
circumcision ceremonies which mark their transition from girlhood
to womanhood, to the moment when they proudly watch their sons make
the transition to elderhood in the eunoto ceremony.
This is one of the most admired of the Disappearing World films,
not least because of the skill and sensitivity with which these
non-literate Masai women are interviewed; the lucidity of
their replies provides insights into what it is to be a Masai woman,
in a manner which enriches the visual material.
The commentary spoken by the anthropologist is detailed without
overburdening the image, and the subtitled translations of women's
songs which express their desire for children and the love they
feel for their moran contribute to making this one of the
high points of the series.
T. O. Beidelman, 1976. Review of the film. American
Anthropologist, Vol. 78, pp. 958959.
P. Spencer, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN, 6,
pp. 1011 (title given as `The Masai; see also letter by M.
Llewelyn-Davies in RAIN, 8, p.16)
For other references see the list under Masai Manhood.
THE MEHINACU
52 minutes Colour
Director: Carlos Pasini
Anthropologist: Thomas Gregor
The Mehinacu live near the head-waters of the River
Xingu in Central Brazil, in a single village within the protective
confines of the Xingu National Park. Although the film concentrates
upon the most exotic aspects of Mehinacu life, focusing on a series
of rituals concerned with the planting and harvesting of the piqui
tree, these rites are firmly located in their social context:
relations between the sexes in this society are formalised in an
astonishing abundance of ritual, celebration, dances and games,
performed to ensure fertile soil and good crops.
Many sequences deal with the daily life of the Mehinacu, showing,
for example, the sexual division of labour, with men fishing and
women preparing manioc. The use of subtitled interviews provides
a depth and sensitivity in the film's approach which helps to underline
the concern with the fact that these Indians are seriously threatened
by a road which is being cut through their territory. One
of the highlights of the film is an interview with a Mehinacu elder
who tells of the origin myth of the sacred flutes, a myth which
is part of a complex belief system that will be lost if the Mehinacu,
who are such a small group, are not able to survive under the pressures
of the outside world.
The film could be used to stimulate discussions of sex role differences,
sexual division of labour in particular societies, and the connection
between ritual and social relationships.
T. Gregor 1970. `Exposure and Seclusion: A Study of
Institutionalized Isolation among the Mehinacu Indians of Brazil'.
Ethnology, Vol. 9, pp. 234250.
T. Gregor 1973. `Privacy and Extramarital Affairs in a Tropical
Forest Community'. In D. Gross (ed.) Peoples and Cultures
of Native South America. Natural History Press, Garden
City.
T. Gregor 1974. `Publicity, Privacy and Mehinacu Marriage'.
Ethnology, Vol. 13, pp. 333349.
T. Gregor 1977. Mehinacu: The Drama of Daily Life
in a Brazilian Indian Village. University of Chicago Press.
S. Hugh-Jones, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN,
6, p.9.
THE MEO
53 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Anthropologist: Jacques Lemoine
Over the last three thousand years the Meo (Miao
or Hmong) have migrated south from north and central China to avoid
oppression and protect their way of life. Today they live
in scattered mountain villages in south China and south-east Asia;
and the 250,000 of them who live in the Kingdom of Laos have suffered
greater losses, relative to their numbers, in the Indo-China wars
than any other single group.
In 1972, when this film was made, the Vietnam war was still at its
peak; therefore it is not surprising that a fairly straightforward
ethnographic account is combined with a more journalistic analysis
of the political situation. Indeed it would be difficult to
approach a discussion of the Meo without such an emphasis, and the
review in RAIN (listed below) is a useful supplement to this.
In effect, the film's narrative divides into two parts: first
we are introduced to a village which managed to remain neutral and
avoid the worst effects of the war (which was why the anthropologist
chose it for his fieldwork). The daily life and material culture
of the Meo people are shown as they sow rice using slash-and-burn
agricultural methods, distil opium for sale and entertainment, and
discuss with the anthropologist their fear of conscription and its
effects on other villages. Two rituals are shown ( the shaman
who performed them was the close friend of the anthropologist) one
to banish a nightmare, the other to exorcise the spirit of a man
which haunts the house of the brother who accidentally killed him
while out hunting.
In the second part of the film we see the Meo who live in American-run
refugee camps (which is the majority of them), far removed form
the village life of their fellows. The interviews with some
of the Meo pilots who fly American B28 bombers over their homeland
emphasise the tragic absurdities of such a war; for these
Meo are not sure exactly who the `enemy' are, each one giving vague
answers to the interviewer's questions.
M. Barber and J. Lemoine 1977. `Two Letters from Indo-China'.
RAIN, 21, pp. 16.
W. Geddes, 1976. Migrants of the Mountains: The Cultural
Ecology of Blue Miao (Hmong Njua) of Thailand. Clarendon,
Oxford.
A. Turton, 1974. Review of the film. RAIN, 4, p. 11.
THE MIGRANTS
55 minutes Colour 1985
Filmmaker: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: David Turton
The Migrants is the third film in the trilogy In
Search of Cool Ground (see entry) made for Granada Television's
Disappearing World series. It is about a drought-induced migration
of Mursi from their traditional territory in the Omo valley to the
Mago valley, about fifty miles away. This migration has brought
them, for the first time, into contact with the market economy of
the Ethiopian Highlands. David Turton notes that, when he first
met the Mursi, men were seldom, and women never, seen at the highland
markets. Now the Mago migrants, and especially women, are familiar
figures in the weekly market at Berka, just four hours walk from
their new settlements.
With their foothold in the pastoral economy weakening (tsetse flies
make the Mago area quite unsuitable for cattle herding) and their
dependence on market exchange growing, the migrants are in the process
of becoming settled agriculturalists, like their highland neighbours,
the Ari. By tracing the present and likely impact of this move on
the lives of the migrants, the film shows how they are beginning
to carve out a new ethnic identity for themselves, as well as a
new home.
D. Turton, 1988. `Looking for a Cool Place: The Mursi, 1890s-1980s'.
In D. Johnson and D. Anderson (eds.) The Ecology of Survival: Case
Studies from Northeast African History, pp. 20182. Lester Crook
Academic Publishing and Westview Press, Boulder and London.
D. Turton and P. Turton, 1984. `Spontaneous Resettlement after
Drought: An Ethiopian Example'. Disasters, Vol. 8, No. 3,
pp. 17889.
L. Woodhead, 1987. A Box Full of Spirits: Adventures of a
Film-maker in Africa. Heinemann, London.
MONGOLIA part 1: ON THE EDGE OF THE GOBI
52 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Adviser: Owen Lattimore
Mongolia is a country the size of Western Europe
with under 1.5 million people but over 23 million head of livestock.
This film concentrates on life in the great plains of Mongolia,
at the foot of the Altai mountains, where the ancient skills of
the Mongol horsemen coexist with the new methods of the socialist
revolution of 1921 which brought collective farming to the steppes.
Professor Owen Lattimore, who serves as commentator, is the West's
leading authority on Mongolia; he first crossed the Gobi in
1926. The Granada film crew were the first documentary unit
allowed in from the West, during summer 1974 and winter 1975.
C. R. Bawden, 1965. `Mongolian Review, October 1965'.
Royal Central Asian Journal. Vol. LII, Parts III and IV, pp.287298.
C. Humphrey, 1974. `Inside a Mongolian Tent'. New Society,
31 October.
O. Lattimore, 1962. Nomads and Commissars: Mongolia
Revisited, Oxford University Press.
O. Lattimore, 1975. Mongol Journeys. AMS Press, New
York.
U. Onon, 1972. My Childhood in Mongolia. Oxford University
Press.
U. Onon, 1976. Mongolian Heroes of the 20th Century.
AMS Press, New York.
A.J.K. Sanders, 1968. The People's Republic of Mongolia.
A General Reference Guide. Oxford University Press.
MONGOLIA part 2: THE CITY ON THE STEPPES
53 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Adviser: Owen Lattimore
The second of two films on Mongolia made by Granada
Television in 197475 looks at life in Ulan Bator, the capital of
Mongolia and home of a quarter of the population. The city
celebrates the 53rd anniversary of the socialist revolution with
parades, festivals, wrestling and archery contests, and a remarkable
horse-race. (The child jockeys are usually between 7 and 12
years old.) The film returns to a shepherd's camp on a collective
for the traditional celebration of Tsagan Sar, the lunar New Year
festival now known as the Herdsman's New Year.
(For references see Mongolia: On the Edge of the Gobi.)
THE MURSI
52 minutes Colour
Director: Leslie Woodhead
Adviser: David Turton
The Mursi, an unadministered tribe living in remote
south-west Ethiopia, are a cattle-keeping and agricultural group
without chiefs or leaders. This film, made under extremely
difficult conditions, focuses on the way decisions are made in this
society at a time of crisis. The crisis occurs when a shortage
of grazing land, during a draught in 1974, led to warfare with their
neighbours, the Bodi. The greater part of the film is concerned
with a debate over the Bodi peace proposals. The Mursi reach
their political decisions in formal debate at which point each warrior
who rises to speak is heard patiently until all the important issues
have been raised and a measure of agreement has emerged.
The Mursi is a serious and important film, both ethnographically
and as a contribution to the understanding of political systems.
K. Fukui and D. Turton (eds.) 1979. Warfare among East African
Herders. Senri Ethnological Studies 3, National Museum of
Ethnology, Osaka, Japan.
W. James and T.B. Selassie, 1976. Review of the film.
RAIN, 16, pp. 67.
D. Turton, 1971. `Mursi Tribe on the Plain of Death'.
Geographical Magazine, September.
D. Turton, 1975. `The Relationship between Oratory and the
Exercise of Influence among the Mursi'. In M. Bloch (ed.),
Political Language and Oratory in Traditional Society. Academic
Press, London.
D. Turton, 1977. `Response to Drought: The Mursi of
Southwestern Ethiopia'. In J.P. Garlick and R.W.J. Keay (eds.),
Human Ecology in the Tropics, Symposia of the Society for the Study
of Human Biology, Vol. XVI. Taylor and Francis, London.
(Reprinted in Disasters, Vol. 1, No. 4, 1978.)
D. Turton, 1978. `Territorial Organisation and Age among the
Mursi'. In P.T.W. Baxter and U. Almagor (eds.), Age, Generation
and Time: Some Features of East African Age Organisations.
Hurst, London.
THE PATHANS
39 minutes Colour
Director: André Singer
Anthropologist: Akbar Ahmed
There are twelve million Pathans. Bound by
a common language, a common heritage and the unifying force of Islam,
these proud and independent people do not acknowledge the geographical
boundary which divides them between Afghanistan and Pakistan.
This film was shot at the same time as Khyber (see RAI Film and
Video Library list) in Pakistan, close to the Afghan border.
The Pathans accept no imposed leadership, from without or from within.
Their laws are the decisions of the democratic assembly of the village,
known as the jirga. To disobey the jirga is to court heavy
penalties against which there is no appeal.
Their code of living is called pukhtunwali the way of the Pathan.
At its core are the principles of hospitality, personal honour and
revenge. A man will fight to the death to avenge a wrong done
to himself, his family or friends or, above all, his women.
The film is noteworthy for the way in which it brings out the importance
of these values.
Their fierce loyalty, coupled with the independence of spirit which
tolerates no formal leaders, makes the Pathans a formidable enemy,
as the British once found out and, more recently, the Soviet invaders
of Afghanistan have discovered.
A. S. Ahmed, 1976. Millenium and Charisma among Pathans. Routlege
and Kegan Paul, London.
A.S. Ahmed, 1980. Pukhtun Economy and Society. Routledge
and Kegan Paul, London.
F. Barth, 1959. Political Leadership among Swat Pathans.
Athlone Press, London.
F. Barth, 1981. Features of Person and Society in Swat:
Collected Essays on Pathans. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
O. Caroe, 1965. The Pathans, 550 B.C. A.D. 1957. Macmillan,
London.
J.S. Spain, 1962. The Way of the Pathans. Robert Hale,
London.
N. Tapper, 1980. Review of the film. RAIN, 38, pp. 56.
R. Tapper, 1974. `Pathan'. Family of Man (Park Work),
Vol. 6, Pt. 79, pp. 22022206. Marshall Cavendish, London.
THE QUECHUA
51 minutes Colour
Director: Carlos Pasini
Anthropologist: Michael Sallnow
This film is set in a community of peasant agriculturalists
2 1/4 miles above sea level in the southern Peruvian Andes.
Concentrating on a single family, the film explores aspects of religious
and secular life. The first part of the film shows a pilgrimage
to a Christian sanctuary situated close to the residence of the
most powerful of the Central Andean mountain spirits (Apus) illustrating
the syncretism of Catholic and pre-Hispanic local religious traditions.
In the second part of the film we see a fertility rite for sheep,
and the attempts of certain members of the community to procure
government assistance for a motor road to the village which would
link them more closely with the rest of Peruvian society.
This film portrays the Quechua of the village of Camahuara as being
in a sense sealed off from the rest of the world, but it also shows
how their way of life is integrated with the Peruvian economy.
It has been criticised for emphasising that the desire for change
is coming from inside the traditional society rather than being
forced on it from without.
O. Harris, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN, 6, p.11.
Reply by Michael Sallnow and further correspondence in RAIN, 7,
10 and 11.
B.J. Isbell, 1978. To Defend Ourselves: Ecology and
Ritual in an Andean Village. Latin American Monographs No.
47. University of Texas Press, Austin.
O. Nunez del Prado and W.F. Whyte, 1973. Kuyo Chico:
Applied Anthropology in an Indian Community. University of
Chicago Press. (An account of a project of directed social
change in a community about 19 km. from Camahuara.)
M. Sallnow, R. Whitburn and V. Cutler, 1978. The Quechua.
Educational pack in the Land and People series intended for 1113
year old children (RAI/ILEA project). Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
W.W. Stein, 1961. Hualcan: Life in the Highlands of
Peru. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
P. Van den Berghe, 1977. Inequality in the Peruvian Andes:
Class and Ethnicity in Cuzco. University of Missouri Press,
Columbia.
THE RENDILLE
51 minutes Colour
Director: Chris Curling
Anthropologist: Anders Grum
The Rendille are camel herders who live in villages
and camps dotted over 10,000 square miles of desert and scrub bush
in Northern Kenya. As the terrain they occupy is so dry, the
Rendille grow no crops and their cultural and economic life is centred
on their animals.
As with other pastoral peoples, the Rendille have to be sensitive
to the ever-shifting relationship between humans, animals and `natural'
resources in order to maintain a suitable balance between them.
Throughout the year the Rendille have to follow the grazing and
rains, dividing their herds between camel camps and semi-permanent
village settlements: long-term planning and decision-making
are therefore crucial and this film brings out the manner in which
the elders make their decisions. Each man gives his opinion
and is listened to attentively until eventually a consensus is reached.
The role of the sexual division of labour and the age-set system
is explained in commentary, interviews and visual sequences, in
a way which allows the viewer insights in the various interacting
levels of Rendille social structure. Sequences detailing the
ritual activities surrounding the naapo ceremony (which marks a
young man's transition to elderhood) are given towards the end of
the film, after explanation of the fact that young men have to live
in camel camps for about 14 years, while girls look after sheep
and goats living in settlements with women and elders. In
this way the building of symbolic villages by moran, each man making
his own `home' with stones representative of wife and children before
sacrificing a goat, is denied status as exotic spectacle:
the subtitled comments of the naapo participants convey their feelings
of embarrassment and uncertainty about the ritual procedure and
allow a visual statement to be made about the relationship of ritual
to every-day life.
The importance of the purely visual images in conveying a sense
of vast desert space, of a daily life filled with the movement and
sight of camels, sheep and goats, and of the social effects of village
layout, is not to be underestimated. Although this colour
film could be criticised for at times beautifying and softening
the rough edges of pastoral life, its power as a statement of what
it means to exist as a Rendille is very much a property of the camera
work. The skilled usage of cinema verite techniques, combined
with full subtitling of interviews, gives to this film an integrity
and sensitivity which serves to reinforce its concern for the Rendille
and its anxiety that for the Kenyan authorities the Rendille are
a problem and an embarrassment.
P.T.W. Baxter, 1977. Review of the film. RAIN, 20, pp. 79.
S. Sato, 1980. `Pastoral Movements and the Subsistence Unit
of the Rendille of Northern Kenya with Special Reference to Camel
Ecology'. Senri Ethnological Studies, No. 6, (African 2),
pp. 178.
G. Schlee, 1979. Das Glaubens - und Socialsystem der Rendille:
Kamelnomaden Nord-Kenyas. (Summary in English, pp. 449464).
Berlin.
P. Spencer, 1973. Nomads in Alliance: Symbiosis and
Growth among the Rendille and Samburu of Kenya. Oxford University
Press, London and New York.
THE SAKUDDEI
53 minutes Colour
Director: John Sheppard
Anthropologist: Reimar Schefold
The Sakuddei are a small and ethnically separate
community living on the island of Siberut off the west coast of
Sumatra in Indonesia. Their distinctive way of life and elaborate
religious ceremonies, centred on the umah (ceremonial house) are
under threat from the Indonesian government which wishes to `civilise'
the Sakuddei. These people are also threatened by a timber
company from the Philippines which has been granted a logging concession
in the Sakuddei's territory.
The first part of the film contains strikingly photographed scenes
of ritual life in the umah, while in the second part there is an
interview with a representative of the government who wants to send
the Sakuddei children to school in a government village on the coast.
The adults fear that the children will lose touch with their own
customs and identity if placed in such an institution. Their
concern forms part of a moving and dramatic film which explores
the contrast between the Sakuddei's way of life and the various
pressures of modern Indonesian society on them: Islam, money,
police, administrators and the lumber companies.
H. Nooy-Palm, 1968. `The Culture of the Pagai-Islands and
Sipora, Mentawei'. Tropical Man, 1, pp. 152241.
R. Schefold, 1973. `Religious Conceptions on Siberut, Mentawai'.
Sumatra Research Bulletin (Berita Kajian Sumatera), II, 2, pp. 1224.
R. Schefold, 1976. `Religious Involution: Internal Change,
and its Consequences, in the Taboo-System of the Mentawaians'.
Tropical Man, 5, pp. 4681.
R. Schefold, 1980. `The Sacrifices of the Sakuddei (Mentawai
Archipelago, Western Indonesia): An Attempt at Classification'.
In R. Schefold, J.W. Schoorl and J. Tennekes (eds.), Man, Meaning
and History: Essays in Honour of Prof. Dr. H.G. Schulte Nordholt.
Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague.
B.E. Ward, 1975. Review of the film. RAIN, 8, pp. 1011.
SHERPAS OF NEPAL
52 minutes Colour
Director: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: Sherry Ortner
Thami is a village 12,000 feet up in the Himalayas
in the Kingdom of Nepal. As the film's opening shots illustrate,
in a type of filmic short-hand, Thami is composed of a patchwork
of individual farms indicative of the Sherpa emphasis on independence
and family self-sufficiency. The main concern of the film
is to examine what it means to be Sherpa today in both cultural
and economic terms: to this end the film concentrates on the
varied career choices of three brothers from Thami peasant farmer,
Buddhist monk and head guide. Interviews with the brothers,
enabling them to express their own attitudes and expectations, deepen
the analysis.
The second half of the film deals with the preparations for the
festivities of a Sherpa wedding, emphasising that negotiations about
bridewealth are lengthy often taking years since marriage is
viewed primarily as an economic transaction. Sequences showing
peasant farming activities, in combination with scenes of Sherpa
life in Katmandu, contrast the old way of life with the new and
illustrate the changing socio-economic conditions encountered by
Sherpas today.
C. von Furer-Haimendorf, 1964. The Sherpas of Nepal.
University of California Press, Berkeley.
E. von Furer-Haimendorf, 1977. Review of the film. RAIN,
21, pp. 78.
S.B. Ortner, 1978. Sherpas through their Rituals. Cambridge
Studies in Cultural Systems, No.2. Cambridge University Press.
THE SHILLUK OF SOUTHERN SUDAN
52 minutes Colour
Director: Chris Curling
Anthropological consultants: Paul Howell, Walter Kunijwok,
André Singer
This film presents a compelling visual and aural
analysis of Shilluk kingship in 1975, and provides a very useful
complement to Evans-Pritchard's 1948 text, The Divine Kingship of
the Shilluk.
Although the Reth (king) has been reduced to the status of second-class
magistrate in dispute settlement by the Sundanese government, he
is still the focus of political and national identity for a Shilluk
people composed of competing territorial groupings. At the
death of the Reth, his spirit passes into the Nile. This film
follows the procession of priests as they carry the effigy of Nyikang,
the 16th century founder of the Shilluk dynasty, and his son Dak
on the pilgrimage from the Nile, retracing the movements of their
conquest of the North, capturing the Reth and installing Nyikang.
The journey is part of a spiritual renewal for the Shilluk, as well
as a renewal of political unity which reaffirms the social order.
The outcome of the journey is known, for the Reth-elect will be
captured after a ritual battle, and only after being possessed by
the spirit of Nyikang will he be installed as King. Thus,
the office is seen to be more powerful than the man, and the continuity
of divine kingship is affirmed.
However, this is not simply a filmed version of the type of analysis
provided in Evans-Pritchard's book, for it deals with the kingship
in a quite different political context. For example, throughout
the period which leads to his installation, the king-elect is guarded
by Government police who are not Shilluk. It is apparent that
the future king accedes to office with the `support' of the Government,
the `mock' aspect of the ritual battle being somewhat confused by
the very real presence of the guards and their disruptive effects
on the proceedings.
In any course on political anthropology this film is clearly crucial,
and for those quick enough to appreciate it, the commentary carries
a great deal of information and analysis. It is also rated
highly for verbal and visual accuracy.
C. Curling 1978. `Anthropology and the General Audience:
Disappearing World'. Educational Broadcasting International,
June, Vol. II, No. 2. (This is not specifically about the
Shilluk but discusses inter alia particular aspects of the film
of interest to anthropologists and filmmakers.)
E.E. Evans-Pritchard, 1948. The Divine Kingship of the Shilluk
of the Nilotic Sudan (The Frazer Lecture of 1948). Cambridge
University Press. (Reprinted in E.E. Evans-Pritchard, Essays
in Social Anthropology. Faber, London, 1962.
E.E. Evans-Pritchard (ed.), 1972. `Shilluk, Sudan'.
In T. Stacey (editorial director), Peoples of the World, Vol. 2,
Africa from the Sahara to the Zambezi. Tom Stacey and Europa
Verlag, [London].
P.P. Howell and W.P.G. Thomson, 1946. `The Death of a Reth
of the Shilluk and the Installation of his Successor'. Sudan
Notes and Records, No. 27, pp. 485.
L. Mair, 1976. Review of the film. RAIN, 12, p. 6.
M.E.C. Pumphrey, 1941. `The Shilluk Tribe'. Sudan Notes
and Records, Vol. 24, Pt. I, pp. 145.
SOME WOMEN OF MARRAKECH
53 minutes Colour
Director: Melissa Llewelyn-Davies
Consultant: Elizabeth Fernea
In Marrakech, traditional attitudes to women prevail
perhaps more strongly than in other Moroccan cities. This
is especially true for those women who live by the standards of
traditional ideals in the Medina, the old city of Marrakech still
enclosed by its ancient walls.
This film attempts to say something about women such as Aisha and
Hajiba two main characters who have experienced the hardships
of life for women in such a society. Aisha's husband is an
unskilled labourer and so she is forced to find work cooking and
cleaning. Hajiba has been thrown out of her natal home by
the brother who became household head on her father's death and
she works as a dancer (shaykha) in a troupe entertaining men for
money. For both of them the ideal of seclusion remains unrealisable,
economic factors taking them out into the public world of men.
The all-women film-crew were privileged to be allowed to attend
a series of events involving women a visit to the steam baths,
a religious celebration, a wedding, a visit to a shuwafa (fortune
teller), a possession cult trance and a trip to the market to buy
cloth. At many of these social events the guests entertain
each other, and the film is remarkable not least for sequences showing
women dancing and playing musical instruments, the brilliant colours
of their dress and surroundings adding to the visual interest.
Some Women of Marrakech is important for the manner in which it
situates these `ethnographic events' in relation to the division
between women in the private world and men in the public world,
providing an analysis which puts in the foreground questions of
women's consciousness, sexuality and male/female division.
K.L. Brown, 1977. Review of the film. RAIN, 19, pp.
79.
L. Brown, 1978. `The Two Worlds of Marrakech'. Screen,
Vol. 19, No. 12, pp. 85118.
E.W. Fernea, 1976. A Street in Marrakech. Anchor/Doubleday,
New York.
V. Maher, 1974. Women and Property in Morocco. Cambridge
Studies in Social Anthropology, No. 10, Cambridge University Press.
THE TUAREG
54 minutes Colour
Director: Charlie Nairn
Anthropologist: Jeremy Keenan
This film is about a group of nomadic Tuareg living
high up in the Hoggar Mountains near Tamanrasset in Algeria.
The main focus of the film is the collapse of the former economic
basis of their camps. In 1962 the Algerian government banned
the system of slavery and contract labour which had helped to keep
the Tuareg camps supplied with grain. Now, instead of undertaking
500 mile long trading journeys to Niger, Tuareg buy grain in Tamanrasset
with money obtained form selling cheap leather goods to the burgeoning
tourist trade. The commentary, by Jeremy Keenan, also introduces
aspects of the Tuareg kinship system, and material about the social
life of the group.
The second part of the film concentrates on the devastating effects
of the recent drought on this way of life. The pasture is
now so poor that camps have to move more frequently, and so traditional
patterns of life are being abandoned in favour of a sedentary existence
as cultivators alongside the Tuareg's former slaves.
J. Keenan, 1978. The Tuareg: People of Ahaggar.
Allen Lane, London.
R. F. Murphy, 1974. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 76, pp. 212213.
UMBANDA
50 minutes Colour
Producer and Director: Stephen Cross
Anthropologist: Peter Fry
Umbanda is a syncretic religious movement, combining
elements from orthodox Catholicism with submerged African and indigenous
Indian spiritual beliefs. In spite of past attempts to suppress
it, Umbanda flourishes in the heterogeneous culture of contemporary
urban Brazil. The film somewhat ambitiously seeks to give
an exposition of the eclectic repertoire of the Umbanda movement.
There is lengthy coverage of ritual performances, including interviews
with mediums and their clients, which emphasise the role the movement
plays in the management of personal malaise and affliction experienced
as a by-product of change and urbanisation.
The concluding sequences of the Sea Goddess, Yemenya identified
with the Virgin Mary show the annual Umbanda festival where half
a million participants from all over the country assemble on the
beaches of São Paulo. The film's strength lies in its graphic
footage of spiritual possession and healing but it has been criticised
for not providing a fuller account of the functioning of Umbanda
groups, and the movement's articulation with the political authorities
in Brazil.
R. Bastide, 1960. Les Religions Africaines au Brésil.
Presses Universitaires de France, Paris.
D. Brown, 1979. `Umbanda and Class Relations in Brazil'.
In M.L. Margolis and W.E. Carter (eds.), Brazil: Anthropological
Perspectives. Essays in Honour of Charles Wagley. Columbia
University Press, New York.
Jean Comaroff, 1978. Review of the film. RAIN, 26, pp.
67.
S. & R. Leacock, 1972. Spirits of the Deep: A Study
of an Afro-Brazilian Cult. Doubleday Natural History Press,
New York.
I.M. Lewis, 1971. Ecstatic Religion: an Anthropological
Study of Spirit Possession and Shamanism. Penguin, Harmondsworth.
R.J. Perelberg, 1980. `Umbanda and Psychoanalysis as Different
Ways of Interpreting Mental Illness'. British Journal of Medical
Psychology, Vol. 53, pp. 323332.
E. Pressel, 1974. `Umbanda Trance and Possession in Sao Paulo,
Brazil'. In I. Zaretsky (ed.), Trance, Healing and Hallucination,
Part Two. Wiley-Interscience, U.S.A.
E. Willems, 1966. `Religious Mass Movements and Social Change
in Brazil'. In E.N. Baklanoff (ed.), New Perspectives of Brazil.
Vanderbilt University Press, Nashville.
Article in T.V. Times, Vol. 89, No. 47, November 1977.
VILLAGERS OF THE SIERRA DE GREDOS
51 minutes Colour 1989
Filmmaker: Peter Carr
Anthropologist: William Kavanagh
The 130 villagers of Navalguijo in the Sierra de
Gredos of Central Spain live in a village perched high in the mountains
and they face an extreme climate with very cold winters and hot
summers. The soil is acid and poor, and the steep slopes and short
growing season mean that agriculture cannot provide a living.
Collectively the villagers own summer pastures high in the mountains,
and individually they hold smaller autumn pastures. With access
to winter pastures across the mountains in the region of Extremadura,
they are able to maintain a large herd of beef cattle, which form
their main source of wealth and which are their dearest possessions.
To make this film, the crew joined the village men on their trek
to Extremadura, when they drive their cattle down the mountains.
This cattle drive is a mixture of hard work and holiday, with passing
round of leather wine bottles, story-telling and evening stopovers
at favourite inns punctuating the long march.
This film portrays a society whose ideals of village co-operation
and the rigid and efficient organisation of tasks have given the
village a strong sense of identity over generations. It remains
to be seen if this sense of identity survives the breakdown of their
isolation from the outside world as tourists discover `hidden Spain'
and better communications and roads bring increasing contact with
the rest of the country.
S. Brandes, 1975. Migration, Kinship and Community: Tradition
in a Spanish Village. Academic Press, London. [Examines a village
not far from the one in the film, but whose economy and style of
life are very different.]
G. Brenan, 1957. South from Granada. Hamish Hamilton, London.
J. Pitt-Rivers, 1971. The People of the Sierra. University
of Chicago Press, Chicago. [Although the book deals with Andalusia
and not with Old Castille where the film is set, it is considered
a classic of Spanish anthropology.]
S. Tax-Freeman, 1970. Neighbours: The Social Contract in a
Castillian Hamlet. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
S. Tax-Freeman, 1979. The Pasiegos: Spaniards in No-man's Land.
University of Chicago Press, Chicago. [Deals with cattle herders
in Santander whose way of life is quite different from that of the
villagers in the film.]
WAR OF THE GODS
66 minutes Colour
Director: Brian Moser
Anthropologists: Peter Silverwood-Cope, Stephen and Christine
Hugh-Jones
While relying on a polemical stance directed against
the cultural genocide wrought by missionaries, War of the Gods also
contains a wealth of information and detail about Amazonian Indian
cosmology, social life and sexual division of labour. Two
groups of Indians from the Vaupés region of Colombia are shown,
the Makú, who live mainly by hunting and gathering, and the sedentary
Barasana, who live mainly by farming.
The film contrasts the belief systems and way of life of the Indians,
presented by the anthropologists who worked and lived with them,
with those of Protestant and Catholic missionaries. The Protestants,
North American Fundamentalists from the Summer Institute of Linguistics,
are said to have used their organisation as a cover in order to
be allowed to work with the Indians, because open Protestant missionary
activity would not have been acceptable to the authorities.
No attempt is made to gloss over the complexities of contact between
Whites and Indians: the Barasana themselves want change, and
the missionaries' influence is undoubtedly more beneficial to the
Indians than that of rubber gatherers. Included in this film
is an interview - using voice-over - with a Makú shaman, and there
are scenes from the Barasana moloka, the communal house which is
a centre of social and domestic activity. The climax of the
film is a contrasting look at a church service at the S.I.L. headquarters,
a Barasana ritual dance (accompanied by the ritual use of the hallucinogen
yagé), and a Mass at the Catholic mission attended by some of the
Indians who took part in the ritual dance.
Some missionaries who have seen this film consider that its editing
is unfair to the S.I.L., but the head of another important missionary
organisation has said that it should be screened during missionary
training courses.
C. Hugh-Jones, 1979. From the Milk River: Spatial and
Temporal Processes in Northwest Amazonia. Cambridge Studies
in Social Anthropology, No. 26. Cambridge University Press.
S. Hugh-Jones, 1978. A Closer Look at Amazonian Indians.
The Archon Press, London. (Book intended for children aged
1014.)
S. Hugh-Jones, 1979. The Palm and the Pleiades: Initiation
and Cosmology in Northwest Amazonia. Cambridge Studies
in Social Anthropology, No. 24. Cambridge University Press.
B. Saler, 1974. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 76, pp. 210212.
THE WHALE HUNTERS OF LAMALERA, INDONESIA
The film vividly and carefully records the technical
process involved in catching cetaceans and large fish, culminating
in the catch itself. R. Ellen
51 minutes Colour 1988
Filmmaker: John Blake
Anthropologist: Robert Barnes
The Whale Hunters of Lamalera was filmed over a
period of four weeks during June 1987. Lamalera is a village which
is perched on the rocky slopes of an active volcano on the southern
coast of the island of Lembata, in Nusa Tenggara Timur in eastern
Indonesia. An anonymous Portuguese document of 1624 describes the
islanders as hunting whales with harpoons for their oil, and implies
that they collected and sold ambergris. This report confirms that
whaling took place in the waters of the Suva Sea at least two centuries
before the appearance of American and English whaling ships at the
beginning of the nineteenth century.
The film follows the daily life of the villagers of Lamalera, a
community of about 1500 people. The Christian Mission has been in
place in the community for a hundred years, schools have been established
and a training workshop teaches carpentry. It is a fishing village
in a region where most communities support themselves by agriculture.
Lamalera has very little productive land, so the villagers have
to fish in order to survive. Their preferred quarry is sperm whale.
Catching sperm whale with hand-thrown harpoons from small open boats
powered by muscle and palm-leaf sail is no easy task, and the hunt
is by no means uneven between man and whale. The tail flukes of
a whale can smash the timbers of the boats and many boats are temporarily
disabled by their prey. Harpooners have been disabled and killed.
But the attraction of the whale is its size. The flesh of the whale
(and shark and manta ray) is cut into strips and sun dried in the
village. The meat is then carried to small markets where it is bartered
with mountain villagers. One strip of dried fish or meat is equivalent
to twelve ears of maize, twelve bananas, twelve pieces of dried
sweet potatoes, twelve sections of sugar cane, or twelve sirih peppers
plus twelve pinang nuts.
Commercial whaling is banned throughout much of the world, but subsistence
whaling is permitted by International Whaling Commission regulations
in Alaska, the USA, the USSR and Greenland. Indonesia is not, however,
a signatory to the IWC. Seven whales were caught in Lamalera in
1987.
R. Barnes, 1989. The Ikat Textiles of Lamalera. E.J. Brill,
Leiden.
R.H. Barnes, 1974. `Lamalerap: A Whaling Village in Eastern
Indonesia'. Indonesia, No. 17, pp. 13759.
R.H. Barnes, 1984. Whaling Off Lembata: The Effects of a Development
Project on an Indonesian Community. IWGIA Document 48. International
Workgroup On Indigenous Affairs, Copenhagen.
R.H. Barnes, 1985. `Whaling Vessels of Indonesia'. In
S. McGrail and E Kentley (eds.) Sewn Plank Boats. British
Archaeological Reports, Oxford.
R.H. Barnes and R. Barnes, 1989. Barter and Money in an Indonesian
Village Economy. Man N.S., Vol. 24, pp. 399418.
R. Ellen, 1988. Review of the film. Anthropology Today, Vol.
4, No. 5, pp. 2324.
THE WODAABE
... is the Wodaabe world disappearing? and how
are we to place the painted male faces? The very considerable success
of this film is the ways it answers these questions. J. Picton
51 minutes Colour 1988
Filmmaker: Leslie Woodhead
Anthropologist: Mette Bovin
The Wodaabe follow their herds in an endless migration
across the borders of Niger, Nigeria, Chad and Cameroon in search
of pasture. The droughts which have ravaged the Sahel since the
late 1960s have devastated Wodaabe cattle herds, and this film looks
at the daily pattern of survival of one hard-pressed family group
at the height of the dry season. Gorjo bi Rima and his family have
been the focus of Mette Bovin's fieldwork since 1968 and she has
seen his herds decline from more than 300 cows to less than half
a dozen. Yet, as she emphasises, the Wodaabe see their life as a
balance between hardship and joy, and the film expresses this in
sequences which record a child's naming feast and the Wodaabe's
obsession with male beauty and adornment. `We like beauty,' Gorjo
says. `We like to see people who are young and handsome and this
is why we put on make-up.' The elaborate make-up of the young men
and their dances, a kind of male beauty contest to gain the attention
of women, are linked to a complex system of taboos which the Wodaabe
insist they will maintain despite mounting pressures to abandon
their nomadic lives.
For another view of the Wodaabe and additional bibliographic references,
see the entry for Deep Hearts (in RAI Film Library Catalogue Volume
II).
A.M. Bonfiglioli, 1988. Dudal. Histoire de Famille et Histoire
de Troupeau Chez un Groupe de Wodaabe du Niger. Cambridge University
Press.
M. Bovin, 1974/5. `Ethnic Performances in Rural Niger: An
Aspect of Ethnic Boundary Maintenance'. Folk (Copenhagen),
Vol. 16/17, pp. 45974.
M. Bovin, 1985. `Nomades "Sauvages" et Paysans "Civilisés":
Wodaabe et Kanuri au Borno'. Journal des Africanistes, Vol. 55,
No. 1/2, pp. 5373.
M. Bovin, 1990. `Nomads of the Drought: Fulbe and Wodaabe
Nomads between Power and Marginalisation (Burkina Faso and Niger
Republic)'. In M. Bovin and L. Manger (eds.) Adaptive Strategies
in African Arid Lands. Scandinavian Institute of African Studies,
Uppsala.
M. Bovin, 1990. `"Mariages de la Maison" et "Mariages
de la Brousse" dans les Sociétés Peules, WoDaaBe et Kanuri
autour du Lac Tchad'. In N. Echard et al (eds.) 4ème Colloque MEGA-TCHAD.
ORSTOM and CNRS, Paris.
M. Dupire, 1975 (1962). Peuls Nomades. Etude Descriptive des
WoDaaBe du Sahel Nigérien. Institut d'Ethnologie, Paris.
J. Picton, 1988. Review of the film. Anthropology Today, Vol.
4, No. 5, p. 23.
C. Ver Eecke, 1989. Review of the film. American Anthropologist,
Vol. 91, pp. 83536.
C. White, 1984. `Herd Reconstruction; The Role of Credit Among
WoDaabe Herders in Central Niger'. Cambridge Anthropology
Vol.9, No.2, pp.3042.
Return to main Video
Sales List.
|